[考題] 假設語氣

[soiris (iris)]

Princess Diana _____ 50 this month,
if she were here now.
(A) would be
(B) would have been
(C) were
(D) was



請問為什麼答案是B阿？這句話不是與現在事實相反嗎？


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 1.167.85.218
※ 文章網址: http://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1399353655.A.27D.html
推 apoka:would be感覺是有可能發生的事情，would have been感覺才是
→ apoka:已經無法改變。
推 apoka:if she were here now才是表達與事實相反
→ apoka:仔細想想A好像也可以... 自己越想越糊塗@____@
推 pttforum:不負責任說：只要是過去的假設就是would have，所以是B
→ pttforum:參考吧~
→ dunchee:已逝的人在用直述句敘述時用過去式。那麼假設句(subjuncti
→ dunchee:ve)呢? 將尋常用法（還活者的人）的subjunctive 動詞態 再
→ dunchee:倒退一格，比如本來(尋常活著的人)是would V -->
→ dunchee:--> Would have Vpp  http://ppt.cc/Svz7 (讀一讀，有幫助
→ dunchee:不管是指"現在"還是"過去"，都是用would have Vpp
→ soiris:感謝大家！