[其他] 請問關於很久以前某雜誌選出來的AI十大最佳表演

[wwwayneya (咖啡)]

剛剛去實境版查了一下

是娛樂週刊選出來的

名單如下

No. 1: Fantasia Barrino
Song ''Summertime''
Date April 14, 2004 (season 3)

No. 2: Kelly Clarkson
Song ''Stuff Like That There''
Date Aug. 6, 2002 (season 1)

No. 3: Elliott Yamin
Song ''A Song for You''
Date April 25, 2006 (season 5)

No. 4: Bo Bice
Song ''In a Dream''
Date May 17, 2005 (season 4)

No. 5: Jennifer Hudson
Song ''Circle of Life''
Date April 6, 2004 (season 3)

No. 6: Chris Daughtry
Song ''Hemorrhage (In My Hands)''
Date March 1, 2006 (season 5)

No. 7: Ruben Studdard
Song ''Superstar''
Date Feb. 11, 2003 (season 2)

No. 8: Clay Aiken
Song ''Solitaire''
Date April 29, 2003 (season 2)

No. 9: Trenyce
Song ''Proud Mary''
Date April 29, 2003 (season 2)

No. 10: Constantine Maroulis
Song ''Bohemian Rhapsody''
Date April 12, 2005 (season 4)

---

我想問的是

有沒有人記得當初的歌單阿

因為怎麼跟我印象中的歌曲和排名有點出入..

前三名我記得的確是那三首

但JH被選出來的歌我印象中是I believe in you and me 耶

而且她這首是從她以前到現在的Live中在我心中的No.1

(也可能是她唯一沒有巨肺高音的一首歌XD)

有沒有人知道到底是我記錯還是怎樣..

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 61.60.217.123
推 tenoe:"當初的歌單"? 這個應該是2007年時選出來的~ 我的印象中，珍
→ tenoe:哈一直都是這首歌上榜。今年不知道EW還有沒有排名....
→ wwwayneya:那可能是我太常聽IBIYAM導致我記憶錯誤  囧
→ thenone:都吹怎麼會是那首  clay的我頗喜歡
→ thenone:最喜歡的是finale表演的wind beneath my wings 錄音版
→ thenone:我比較喜歡他唱這種風格 專輯風格感覺不太能最佳發揮特色
→ thenone:都沒感覺