[文法] 兩題互相矛盾的國中文法題目

[each0989 (each)]

1.
A: Who read you the letter last night?  B: _____.　
(A) It was Dad.  (B) Yes, my mom did
(C) No, I didn't read it.  (D) My mom does.

為何這題答案可以是(A)?

過去式問句中沒Be動詞只有一般動詞,應該用xx did不是嗎?

還有,這問句的意思是"昨天晚上是誰讀這封信給你聽"對吧?

2.
A: Who broke the window?  B: ____　
(A) It was John.  (B) It wasn't me.　
(C) Mary did.　(D) My young brother does.

而這題的答案(A)卻是錯的,要選(C)

搞的我好亂啊....

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 220.129.120.205
推 noruas:1. 這樣解題..太過火了吧 @@
→ noruas:要以語言自然習慣來看..It was dad. 或 My dad.
→ noruas:當然,回答 My dad did.也可以.但不是應該或絕對必須這樣答
推 memorabilia:我想說第1題的答案給的好爛...
→ memorabilia:第1題應該是出現在分裂句的文法中: It was Dad who...
→ memorabilia:第2題(A)選項 大概是出題的人忽略了有分裂句的寫法
→ dunchee:分裂句有它的適用場合。事實上這用法的形成是因為*書寫*
→ dunchee:文字無法像(當面)口頭說那樣用語氣/肢體語言強調，所以2
→ dunchee:用It was Dad who .... 反而奇怪。  原PO剩下的問題我回在
→ dunchee:http://dunchee.blogspot.com/2011/01/temp_28.html
推 DialUp:1.答案可以是It was Dad who read the ...或 My Dad did.