推 flac:如果是E的話 第二個頭銜是否也要加former? 09/04 13:10
※ 引述《flac (老獅子)》之銘言：
: As the former chair of the planning board for 18 consecutive years and a
: board member for 28years, Joan Philkill attended more than 400 meetings
: and reviewed more than 700 rezoning applications.
: (A) As the former
: (B) The former
: (C) Former
: (D) She was
: (E) As the
: 我選A 答案是E PP筆記的說明表示
: A as the former chair… for 18 consecutive years不符合邏輯，而且主詞動詞是
: attended…，如果是 former chair，attended…也是不符合邏輯的。
: former是從前的 以前的 為什麼多了這字 就變的不合邏輯
: 是因為配合後面 ...and a board member...的關係嗎? 也就是因為所用的動詞為
: attended 兩個職位必須是同時擁有 所以前面的職位不能用former?
: 煩請賜教 謝謝
(B)(C)(D) 缺謂語,排除
(A)(E) 應該是邏輯上的差異
(A)沒有 former 會讓人誤以為JP現在還是 chair of the planning board
(E)加了 former 之後讓人清楚JP 是前任的, 而且沒有加former也有改變題意之嫌疑!
有錯誤請指教囉!!
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 219.86.164.180