[請益] Voiced Aspirated Stops

[twowugs (T.C.)]

前一陣子有討論提到部分語言如梵語有voiced aspirated stops
剛剛讀書看到這段

"In Hindi there is a series of stops sometimes INCORRECTLY
 referred to as VOICED ASPIRATED STOPS that make use of
 whispery voice (murmur)."

這意思是說這類聲音應該算是murmur，只是不同glottal state造成的影響

我想Hindi和梵語很接近，發音應該可以比較
那到底有沒有真的voiced aspirated stops呢?

我之前一份作業有類似的問題
提到aspirated n是不可能的，因為

"Aspiration indicates a delay in the onset of voicing of
 a vowel following the release of a voiceless stop; nasals
 can't be aspirated because they are voiced."

簡單講就是voiced nasal不會有aspiration
因為會有aspiration是前面stop的voiceless-ness延後了下一個vowel voicing的時間

我想這種說明應該不限於nasals，應該包括所有voiced stops
所以實際上應該沒有voiced aspirated stops，這樣對嗎?

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 118.166.48.2
推 parachutes:我記得古英文有voiced aspirated stops耶@@"
推 Asvaghosa:古英文沒有吧