Re: [問題] 全壘打被沒收

[mrkey (距離太遠 思念太近)]

官網今天的新聞, 節錄幾段出來:     from http://atmlb.com/ZRXkFL

Major League Baseball issued a statement Thursday regarding the disputed
instant-replay ruling in the ninth inning of Wednesday's A's-Indians game,
acknowledging the call was "improper," but saying it will stand as final.

In the wake of what appeared to be a game-tying homer but ruled a double,
leading to the ejection of A's manager Bob Melvin before the Indians held on
for a 4-3 victory, MLB executive vice president for baseball operations Joe
Torre said via a statement:

"By rule, the decision to reverse a call by use of instant replay is at the 
sole discretion of the crew chief. In the opinion of Angel Hernandez, who was 
last night's crew chief, there was not clear and convincing evidence to 
overturn the decision on the field. It was a judgment call, and as such, it 
stands as final.

"Home and away broadcast feeds are available for all uses of instant replay, 
and they were available to the crew last night. Given what we saw, we 
recognize that an improper call was made. Perfection is an impossible 
standard in any endeavor, but our goal is always to get the calls right.
Earlier this morning, we began the process of speaking with the crew to 
thoroughly review all the circumstances surrounding last night's decision."


文章後面還有兩段就是昨晚那個 play 的文字敘述就恕刪了. 簡單來說, statement 就以

"沒有很清楚的證據顯示可以改判" 為由. 表示此判決為 "不恰當", 但就此結案.


不意外 Joe Torre 會以這樣的方式結案 (or, 河蟹)

畢竟這是 official standard. 科科.

Angel Hernandez 再度逃過一劫.

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 76.117.52.242
推 seeyou1002:河蟹無國界
推 zino0310:本來就不可能改判  連Gallaraga這麼明顯的誤判  都沒還他
→ zino0310:一場完全比賽  更何況這一發只是162場中的一發追平彈
→ kkkk3145:只能處罰，比賽結束，不可能改判的~
→ zino0310:而且聯盟應該都抱持著場上事在場上解決  比賽結束就一切
→ zino0310:就底定  誰都不想開結束後改判的先例  否則沒完沒了
推 cliff02468:好河蟹不吃嗎
推 dp44:教練都被驅逐出場了  還要怎麼場上解決
→ dp44:大家都在罵Angel Hernandez  可是難道4個壘審都眼殘?
→ dp44:還是有什麼不能說的秘密:P
推 ck6a83:討論的結果是  我們不想加班
推 catsondbs:官方擺明不理你 "對不我們是錯了, 不過運動家你吞了吧"
推 flycat638:那場PG連歐巴馬都出聲情願還給投手，不過聯盟還是沒還
→ flycat638:記得是這樣
→ sdiaa:官官相衛阿
→ CarMartinez:基本上最多就只能處罰 不可能改判  運動家也只能吞了
推 giunrz:看來聯盟也愛叫球隊把委屈吞下去
噓 Dimitre:不得不噓
推 momo90347:Gallaraga的PG TAT
推 davidex:棒球回不去奧運不是沒道理的
推 purification:回不去不是因為這樣 其他運動黑哨也沒比較少
推 tonyselina:各項運動哪有事後改判的? 除非球迷暴動跟吃藥
推 jeffl0402:棒球應該可以成為誤判較少的一項運動 但老子就是不爽弄~
推 ihsan:一壘不久前才有一個改判例子
→ micotosai:說回不會的也好笑，你要不要去看跆拳道跟劍擊再來說嘴
推 yrt3168:回不去咧 = = 最黑的明明就是跆拳.......
→ yrt3168:棒球已經算誤判很少的了
推 ypw:那場PG  我還是覺得一壘手接球時未掌握  球是跳動中  沒悲情
推 holabear:跆拳道是最不黑的比賽，在"比賽選手都是南韓人的時候。"