推 fatfatfat :其實是說 他認為Kidd沒有Cuban排名那麼高（PG第一） 02/14 13:05
→ fatfatfat :但又沒有Hollinger排的那麼低（PG第15） 02/14 13:06
http://tinyurl.com/attvpg
Jason Kidd is headed to Cabo, not Phoenix, for the weekend. He's fallen from
the ranks of the All-Stars.
Mark Cuban can make a case (with confusing statistical evidence) that Kidd
has been the league's best point guard this season. ESPN.com stat geek John
Hollinger can make a case (with confusing, subscription-required statistical
evidence) that Kidd has been middle of the pack among starting point guards.
The truth is probably somewhere in the middle.
How many point guards would you take over Kidd right now? I'm not asking
about trade scenarios, so forget age, contracts, etc. I'm asking which guys
you'd rather have running your team for the rest of the season.
New Orleans' Chris Paul and Utah's Deron Williams are no-brainers. San
Antonio's Tony Parker and Denver's Chauncey Billups are pretty close to that
category. The rest of the good/great PGs are up for debate.
Hollinger's Player Efficiency Rating system ranks Kidd 15th among point
guards this season, but that includes Jason Terry, whose minutes at the point
are few and far between with Kidd on the scene.
Devin Harris ranks second behind Paul, but Cuban would still pull the trigger
on the Harris/Kidd deal "100 out of 100 times," as he's said about 100 times.
The Mavs haven't been better with Kidd than Harris, so I'll stick Harris in
the group of point guards I'd take over Kidd right now.
And that might be it.
Others we haven't mentioned whom Hollinger has ranked above Kidd: Orlando's
Jameer Nelson (injured), Toronto's Jose Calderon (no defense), Boston's Rajon
Rondo (had a triple-double on the Mavs last night and earned a ring last
season), Philadelphia's Andre Miller, New York's Nate Robinson (yuck),
Milwaukee's Ramon Sessions (zero playoff experience), Atlanta's Mike Bibby
and Phoenix's Steve Nash. Cleveland's Mo Williams is right behind Kidd.
看標題別想太多
這篇有點是在反駁Cuban的數據程式
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 220.136.176.202