[轉錄]Re: [外絮] Marion, Turkoglu Four-Way Deal Done

[popstarkirby (opostarkirby)]

※ [本文轉錄自 Raptors 看板]

作者: keith2822 (變) 看板: Raptors
標題: Re: [外絮] Marion, Turkoglu Four-Way Deal Done
時間: Fri Jul 10 04:37:29 2009

Grading The Deal: Mavs Get Marion In Four-Way Trade
Authored by Christopher Reina - July 9, 2009 - 2:23 pm


http://mavericks.realgm.com/articles/66/20090709/grading_the_deal_mavs_get_
marion_in_four-way_trade/

打分數囉！國外Realgm網站對此交易的評分

====
Grade for Dallas: B

Mark Cuban is like Max Fiscer at Grover Cleveland high school; really making
a go of it.

With Dirk Nowitzki, Jason Kidd, Josh Howard, Jason Terry, Erick Dampier and
now Shawn Marion and Marcin Gortat, Dallas has an excellent top-seven and on
paper has enough teeth to be a true contender in the Western Conference.

During Marion's best years in Phoenix, he was a garbage scorer playing off of
Steve Nash lobs and the attention being served up front to Amare Stoudemire.
Marion was clearly a far less effective player in Miami and Toronto when
asked to have a bigger offensive role, so it remains unclear if he has simply
lost his ability to be productive or simply can't be productive in a system
where he is a lead offensive player.

That is the $39 million question Dallas will find out in year one or two,
because the Mavericks will have a major overhaul before Marion's contract is
up. I don't believe Marion is worth the price tag, but to Dallas he can be
the factor that pushes them forward and so with significant money already
invested, Marion becomes a type of insurance.

Even at his advanced age, Kidd is the right kind of point guard to pair with
Marion and they will benefit each other. Marion was underrated in how much he
assisted Nash in running the SSOL offense, due to his versatility and how
active he was on both sides of the floor.

This move is a continuation of keeping Kidd and getting Gortat. As soon as
they invested in the short-term with Kidd, they had to make another move to
go all-in and this is precisely it.

Similar to the aging process already underway in San Antonio, the Mavericks
have a quickly closing window and the pressure is on Nowitzki because he has
enough weapons surrounding him to return to the Finals.

加上Marion和Gortat後現在小牛有七名優秀球員
一、二年後Marion平均約8M的約可能會有點麻煩
作者認為約簽的有點高，但Marion的到來可幫助小牛前進

====
Grade for Raptors: A

Toronto has now essentially traded Charlie Villanueva for Hedo Turkgolu and
Antoine Wright. Considering they were both free agents this summer and
Turkoglu was vastly more coveted, I think you can call it a drawn out
convoluted win for the club. Villanueva became T.J. Ford, who became Jermaine
O'Neal, who became Marion, who became Turkoglu.

Because of this acquisition, the Raptors will now have flexibility to sign
another contributing role player.

作者認為暴龍等於是拿Villanueva換到Turkgolu和Wright
Villanueva<->T.J <->Jermaine O'Neal <-> Marion <-> Turkoglu
保留下來的薪資空間將有助於再找其他球員來輔助核心球員..

====
Grade for Magic: B+

Orlando gets a tidy $8 million trade exception for agreeing to sign-and-trade
Turkoglu. Given their cap situation, I would be surprised if the trade
exception gets used, but it is a valuable asset to have nevertheless.

But when Orlando acquired Rashard Lewis in a sign-and-trade, they had to send
Seattle a draft pick, something Otis Smith didn't do here with Bryan
Colangelo.

8M的TE增加未來交易的操作彈性

=====
Grade for Grizzlies: A

Memphis was essentially paid $2.5 million as purely a facilitator. Chris
Wallace has become the Prop Joe of the NBA. He was in on the Houston, Orlando
Kyle Lowry/Rafer Alston three-way and completed dumps for Chris Mihm, Shaun
Livingston and Steve Francis in just the past few months.

救援王當之無愧....

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 114.32.180.102
推 tshih:結果Bank還是沒有丟出去= =
→ tshih:by the way 現在暴龍官網的進站有火槍兵影片喔~~~
推 BrentRoy:看到了 暴龍15號還是蠻好看的
→ popstarkirby:借我轉0.0
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 210.69.175.253
→ popstarkirby:個人評價:A+!
→ popstarkirby:小牛拿沒有在用的球員換到明星球員，又清掉兩張約
推 dipsy       :感覺這是薪資控制評價...
推 dirk418     :A+
推 combo896    :A++,其實跟湖人換GASOL有異曲同工之妙
推 jazz123457  :如果能把丹皮交易來個kkman之類那整體評價就是S了XD
推 koming      :這種交易..去年應該是被當成幻想文吧...XD
→ timsid99    :A
→ dmdjjj      :有點高嗎 Marion上季的末年薪水可是17M阿
→ dmdjjj      :主要還是抓到暴龍想要火槍 但是直接丟Marion又可惜的
→ dmdjjj      :心態去促成這筆
→ popstarkirby:如果上季交易來他...我們可要多花9M
推 muyang1016  :A+