[雜事] 大家來找碴 Part 1

[bluetai (夏日香氣--孫藝珍)]

我竟然忘了把自己排進去互評系統名單~
請有空的人幫我看一下嚕~
也歡迎其他人一起貼出來互相觀摩~
=================================================
This paper proposes three techniques to enhance the
readability of the complicated higher level diagrams.
Those three techniques are the vectorization of
repetitive, the improved feedback loop breaking algorithm,
and the simplification of bundle net connections using flat taps.

Authors define two sets of rules in Sections 3.2 and 3.3
to simplify the bundle net connections and increase the
abstraction of circuits, respectively. However, those two
sets of rules are very trivial.

According to an observation which was proposed in [7],
authors add a BFS before the DFS of Tarjan [1] in
Section 3.1 to break the feedback loops. In Section 3.4,
authors modified Yoeli's robust channel routing
algorithms [8] to handle vertical ordering. Nevertheless,
those two algorithms are slightly modified from previous work.

In Table 1, most of gate level modules have larger symbols,
segments, length, and area than system and register
transfer levels. According to the results, it seems that
proposed techniques cannot handle larger circuits well.
Besides, please compare your results with previous work.
Even though previous work focused on gate level designs,
you should compare results for the four gate levels modules.

Please report your running time in your results. Although
the reduction ratios of symbols, segments, length, and
area are important issues in this problem, fast running
time is also a main issue for this problem.

Finally, please check Figure 5. In the line 2 on
function HorizontalOrderRec(), I do not think that the
loop will terminate. Besides, I think that the symbol, n, should
be f in line 10.

--

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.112.233.88
※ 編輯: bluetai         來自: 140.112.233.88       (05/28 06:09)
※ 編輯: bluetai         來自: 140.112.233.88       (05/28 07:07)
推 yellowfishie:第5行 simplication -> simplification ?
推 yellowfishie:倒數第六行 fast running time "is"
推 yellowfishie:... also "a" main issue
推 bluetai:感恩again~ 看來寫comments前還是要睡個覺~ XD
※ 編輯: bluetai         來自: 140.112.233.88       (05/28 16:55)