1. 領域：Computer networking
2. 期刊名稱：IEEE Transactions on Mobile Computing
3. 被accepted/revised/rejected：reject (自己withdraw)
4. 投稿後大約多久才收到結果：
(2009/10/15投稿 ~ 2010/01/28收到major revision通知)
5. reviewer的數目：3
審了有三個月, 拿到major revision,
三個reviewer分別給minor revision, major revision, 與directly reject.
給directly reject的那位給的是極端強烈的意見,
譬如: I have serious doubt on the security strength of the paper.
And do not think it is something possible to address.
而且AE也幾乎是指明了一定要正面回答這位reviewer讓他滿意我們才能過關,
基於這位reviewer真的是抓到我們的痛腳, 我們這篇就自己withdraw掉了.
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.112.6.89