[請益] 黃金閱讀29篇 第13篇ARCHITECTURE 第8題

[oscillation (Gone Too Soon)]

段落:

Paragraph 5:

Modern architectural forms generally have three separate
components comparable to elements of the human body; a supporting skeleton
or frame, an outer skin enclosing the interior spaces, equipment,
similar to the body’s vital organs and systems. The equipment includes
plumbing, electrical wiring, hot water, and air-conditioning. Of course in
early architecture—such as igloos and adobe structures—there was no such
equipment, and the skeleton and skin were often one.

題目:

8. Which of the following correctly characterizes the relationship between
   the human body and architecture that is described in paragraph5?

1○ Complex equipment inside buildings is the one element in modern
    architecture that resembles a component of the human body.

4○ In general, modern buildings more closely resemble the human body than
    earlier buildings do.

以上是我有問題的兩個選項

答案是最後一個選項，我想請問上面的選項有哪裡錯誤嗎 ?

我寫第二次的時候，還是看到第一個選項就選下去了 >__<

請問是因為敘述多了 "complex" equipment 因此不對

還是因為單純第四個選項是比較好的呢?

謝謝解答

--
常常遇到鬼打牆的狀況，邏輯不好Q__Q


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 220.140.114.209
※ 編輯: oscillation     來自: 220.140.114.209      (08/16 15:55)
推 reneemorris:應該是選項一只說明了部分事實吧 沒提到其他兩個要素
※ 編輯: oscillation     來自: 220.140.114.209      (08/16 16:36)
推 TETZ:這題我也覺得好奇怪 4也可以說human body並不只那三部分啊
推 huao:1的答案 Complex equipment是body's vital organs and system
→ huao:4的答案 因為舊有的房子沒有足夠比擬為人體的條件 所以正確