[請益] TPO11 begging by nestlings

[cloudballoon (氣球雲)]

  Paragraph 4：Given that predators can make it costly to beg for food, what benefit do begging
nestlings derive from their communications? One possibility is that a noisy baby bird provides
accurate signals of its real hunger and good health, making it worthwhile for the listening
parent to give it food in a nest where several other offspring are usually available to be fed. If
this hypothesis is true, then it follows that nestlings should adjust the intensity of their signals in
relation to the signals produced by their nestmates, who are competing for parental attention.
When experimentally deprived baby robins are placed in a nest with normally fed siblings, the
hungry nestlings beg more loudly than usual—but so do their better-fed siblings, though not as
loudly as the hungrier birds.
Paragraph 5：If parent birds use begging intensity to direct food to healthy offspring capable of
vigorous begging, then parents should make food delivery decisions on the basis of their offsprings
calls. Indeed, if you take baby tree swallows out of a nest for an hour feeding half the set and starving
the other half, when the birds are replaced in the nest, the starved youngsters beg more loudly than
the fed birds, and the parent birds feed the active beggars more than those who beg less vigorously.
9. In paragraphs 4 and 5, what evidence supports the claim that the intensity of nestling
begging calls is a good indicator of which offspring in a nest would most benefit from a feeding?
○ When placed in a nest with hungry robins, wellfed robins did not beg for food.
○ Among robin nestlings, the intensity of begging decreased the more the nestlings were fed.
○ Hungry tree swallow nestlings begged louder than well-fed nestlings in the same nest.
○ Hungry tree swallow nestlings continued to beg loudly until they were fed whereas well-fed
nestlings soon stopped begging.


###想知道為何B不行  答案是C


10. It can be inferred from paragraphs 4 and 5 that parent songbirds normally do not feed
○ nestlings that are too weak to beg for food as vigorously as their nestmates
○ more than one hungry nestling during a single visit to the nest
○ offspring that were fed by the parents on the previous visit to the nest
○ nestlings that have been removed and then later put back into their nest

###想知道為何C不行  答案是A

懇請大大們幫忙解釋一下!!!

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 111.249.45.22
→ kenosxx:第一題b選項說nestlings叫聲強度變小就被餵越多跟文章不符
→ kenosxx:第二題主要考的是問你父母餵小孩的根據,從文章來看是根據
→ kenosxx:叫聲強弱跟父母有沒有餵過小孩子沒有強烈關係
→ cloudballoon:b 不是說 強度月小表示愈多已經被餵了嗎?
→ kenosxx:叫聲強度越小→就會被餵越多  因果關係弄反了
→ kenosxx:他並不是說被餵越多叫聲就會越小