[討論] Goal.com 阿根廷 0-4 德國 賽後評分

[jim1029 (大宗)]

ARGENTINA (4-3-3)

Romero: 5 - Could have done better at the first goal and failed to truly
assert himself after that. Granted he had relatively little to do.

Otamendi: 3 - Completely and utterly out of his depth. Sold the jerseys for
Mueller's opener with a failure to challenge in the air; lunged in with
colossal naivete to free Podolski to create Germany's second. Hooked after
that.

Burdisso: 5.5 - The best of the Argentine defenders on show - not that this
is saying much. In fact the reason he was the top performer is that he kept
himself out of the way and didn't make mistakes.

Demichelis: 4.5 - Unable to settle down the back line, and torn to shreds by
his Bayern team-mates, amongst others. A worrying performance for all
concerned.

Heinze: 4 - Achingly slow and clearly not mentally equipped for the battle
that ensued in the second period. Never stopped running, it's true - but he
probably should have done from time to time to consider his options.

Maxi Rodriguez: 6 - Not quite as bad as the scoreline would suggest, Maxi
seldom posed a threat but at least managed to retain possession in his
midfield role. A calming influence.

Mascherano: 6 - Again, Argentina could have done with more like him. Tough in
the tackle, which eventually brought him a booking but perhaps helped keep
the score down.

Di Maria: 5.5 - Certainly looked the part on the ball... at least until it
left his boot, or failed to do so. Lacked any ability or foresight in timing
his pass or shot, and as such undid all his good work.

Higuain: 4 - A shocker from the Real Madrid man, who would be the first to
admit that he can do better. Creaky and slow in reaching any given ball, and
not in the game in terms of finishes.

Messi: 7 - Showed some moments of magic in the first half but ultimately
couldn't break down the obstinate German back line.

Tevez: 6 - Had a few good flashes but didn't connect with his   team-mates.
This of course, is as much as their fault as his.


Substitutes

Pastore: 5.5 - Throwing in a youngster to change a game doesn't always pay
off. Such was the case here. Very energetic but lacked focus.

Aguero: 5





GERMANY (4-2-3-1)

Neuer: 6 - Despite keeping a clean sheet the Schalke man showed why he is not
first choice ahead of Rene Adler with a nervy showing comprising several
spilled balls.

Lahm: 6.5 - Very much dependable in the defensive sphere but tended to waste
the ball. Not his finest hour, but nonetheless a good performer.

Mertesacker: 7.5 - On those rare occasions that Argentina managed to break
into the box, Per was there to halt them, particularly (as one might expect)
in the air.

Friedrich: 8 - Despite being regarded as a weak link prior to the tournament,
Friedrich was in inspired form for this match, even picking up a goal.

Boateng: 7.5 - The full-back found himself beaten once or twice, but seldom
in a truly dangerous position. This was an excellent tactical performance.

Khedira: 8 - A fine, solid performance from one of Jogi Loew's first picks.
It's abundantly clear to see why he's considered undroppable.

Schweinsteiger: 9.5 - And here's another one who won't be away from the team
anytime soon. What a performance from Basti. Spent most of the game
marshalling the defensive midfield but also found the time to provide assist
after assist. In effect, plays as two men.

Mueller: 8 - Less than ten caps? He plays like he's been doing this all his
life - and that's because he doesn't try to do what he can't. (Take a note,
Angel di Maria.) Short passing, directed running - oh, and a goal as well.

Oezil: 7 - A quiet yet pleasing performance from one of the breakout stars of
this tournament. His cross for Klose's curtain call was delicious.

Podolski: 7.5 - He's done a lot better than this in terms of converting
product, but one thing that can be said for Poldi is that his activity on the
wing keeps his opponents occupied even when he's not crossing or scoring. We
saw that against Australia and we saw it against far tougher opposition here.

Klose: 9 - It was just two tap-ins, they say. Rubbish. You can only tap in if
you're in the correct position, and that's what Klose does best. He may not
score at club level but the Germans cannot do without his teamwork and
finishing. The consummate Jogi Loew player: knows exactly what to do and does
it well.

Substitutes

Jansen: 8 - OK, the game was already over, but he's actually given Loew a bit
of thinking to do now. In twenty minutes he accomplished tons.

Kroos: 6

Trochowski: 6.5


--

Top of the Match ：Schweinsteiger B. Germany
Flop of the Match：Otamendi N.       Argentina

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 140.112.239.203
→ mehr:小豬果然最高分
推 oklaforever:9.5耶
推 magita6002:有到9分喔O.o
→ zc622:9.5 (Y)
推 shadow0326:小豬真的不簡單
推 ashinism:想問有板友知道為什麼肥馬不派Milito上嗎?
推 fourmemory:這是他應得的...
→ rex01:Otamendi 3分不意外，他要為這場輸球負上很大的責任
推 Inesse:＝w＝ 德國每個人都很棒＞＜
推 realfree:哇! 9.5  這屆有出現過嗎?
推 yvonne918:小豬今天好棒:)
推 www90173:拉母  低分
推 bosskiss00:推一下小豬!!!
→ nicklee0921:9.5...這是體操的分數嗎@@
推 snowshadow7:Higuain 囧
→ rsjn:每次都很疑惑LAHM都好低 明明就守得很好@@
→ skypons:LAHM無名英雄阿！
→ bosskiss00:阿瓜太愛幹了....低分不意外
推 Simonfenix:In effect, plays as two men.
→ marcoyao:諾伊爾有點低
→ rex01:Schweinsteiger: 9.5 ─ 表現得有如有兩個人在場上一樣
推 jonsauwi:Neuer竟然才6啊...@@ 不過Schweinsteiger真是MOM沒話說
→ greymon62:Lahm給的太低了吧QQ
推 BlueNEO:9.5耶 小豬
→ rex01:小豬終於學會影分身之術
→ Ninboke:小豬好棒!!!!!
→ kobesnoopy:Lahm真的是無名英雄...  應該要高分一點吧
→ vell:槓 德國每個人都好高分XD
→ tliu223:轟炸超人回饋德甲﹗﹗﹗﹗
推 lynnjure:因為用臉把具威脅性的球擋下來了啊 拉姆因為進攻被扣了
→ kodwsg:小豬9.5好高啊!!!
推 skypons:不爽的是年代左邊的大鼻主播一直把Higuain念成西瓜因...
→ NANASAN:Lahm踢得很好..很穩
推 lostsomeone:Lahm表現很好啊~~
推 Mez:Neuer 擋的都很認真耶 應該要更高分~
推 garcia:伊瓜因今天是跟顆西瓜沒兩樣啊...
推 singlesky:curtain call是什麼?  德國每個人都好高分!!
推 moamo:小豬應該是篤定進入今年最佳11人中場了
※ Bionut:轉錄至看板 Bundesliga                                    07/04 01:18
推 itachi0609:小豬超高 Lahm太低了點
推 amida959:只剩MESSI還有7..................慘烈
推 IronHand:看到這篇就想到前幾篇有人還說messi沒有足球智商很可笑
→ IronHand:很為messi感到不平 沒有好的隊友 孤臣無力以回天
推 retsuya001:推!!大家都很棒
推 harms:Lahm和Neuer感覺跟隊友的評分方式有差(?)
推 kery0129:Lahm分數也太低了吧 至少也該給個8分
推 pinestudy:Goal.com好像比較偏愛有進攻貢獻的球員
→ pinestudy:以Lahm來說 對迦納那場得到8分 主要理由是助功貢獻
→ pinestudy:即使Goal.com也評Lahm那場防守有時不夠好 但還是高分
→ pinestudy:之後兩場Lahm守得更好 但進攻較沒表現 分數就只有6和6.5