Re: Review: Ashkenazy's Bach Well-Tempered Clavier

[ChaosCreator ()]

※ 引述《ivanos (巴西中場羅納迪諾)》之銘言：
: When this CD was just released, I thought much about whether I should
: buy this work. There are already so many master interpretations, including
: those played by Glenn Gould, Richter, Tureck, Nikolayeva, and Schiff.
: And there were quite few reviews about this new work by Ashkenazy when it
: was just released.
: But I still gave it a try. And, WOW!, I am glad that I have made the purchase
: decision. As a pianist, Ashkenazy seldom dissatisfies his audiences recently.
: His Shostakovich Preludes & Fugues is a good example. And this Bach
: Well-Tempered Clavier is no exception. The style of the whole work is a little
: like Sviatoslav Richter PLUS Glenn Gould. The rhythm is rich, fresh and
: colorful with the spiritual sound produced by Ashkenazy's beautifully
: using the pedals. If someone wonders whether it is bland, I can tell you
: it definitely is not. Ashkenazy possesses the animation of Glenn Gould but
: proceeds without GG's sometimes eccentricity. Ashkenazy expresses the
: beautiful sound and smooth rhythm of Sviatoslav Richter but bounces and
: rocks more! However, in addition to all the above features, you can still
: feel and appreciate Ashkenazy's unique understanding of this classic.
: And his uniqueness is pretty.
: This is a masterwork played by a master. Take it, and put it among those
: previous interpretations. We have a new classic.

=>>第一片聽完感覺很好，能塞成三片CD是利用加大快慢落差達到的，
   但他的處理不會讓人感到突兀，反而沈思後灌注活力的效果。
   在慢速的段落會讓人有『這是Ashkenazy嗎？』的感覺。
   Ashkenazy的偏亮音色在快速段落偶有讓我覺得被打擾，但瑕不掩瑜，
   錄音極好，是Decca繼Schiff版以後又一力作。
   有了這張，我想好一陣子我不需要添購平均率了，
   也完全不後悔當初把Dynamic特價那套拿去送人：P

=>>第一片第十九軌，23秒到26秒還有鳥叫聲，算是很美妙的意外，
   這種場地噪音常常會打斷聽者感受，但這邊是很少數有增色奇效的例子。


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 61.64.142.7
推 littlefive:平均律  偷抓板主錯字(逃)
→ littlefive:話說國外教授推薦 Colin Tilney版, 似乎絕版  有消息嗎
推 ivanos:鳥叫聲  聽你說了才發現  interesting
推 ivanos:說到收平均律  收完這張暫時也差不多了
→ liyin:這套頗優，但我更推薦新世代經典的Afanssiev版（Denon）
推 Volodos:我只有買到 Tilney 的 toccata, 超級精典的演出
→ Volodos:不知台灣有 Tilney 的 WTC 全集可買乎?
→ littlefive:www.jsbach.org 上面說 Tilney 是 hyperion 發行
→ littlefive:到佳佳問, 林小姐說只聽過 angela hewitt 版 orz
→ littlefive:猜想是絕版已久  版友若有消息麻煩告知 <(_ _)>