推 ChaosCreator:如果還沒下架到是個趁機進些難找沒重發演奏的機會:P 03/12 20:31
→ arabeske:樂評沒栽掉啊?!相反的,還顯示出他們的標準還滿一致的 03/12 20:53
→ Dussek:可是如果原演奏版本受到的評價不高，那就栽了 :p 03/12 20:59
推 louis0407:樓上XDDDY 03/12 22:41
幾張在ClassicsToday網站被評為10/10的Hatto專輯
網站選擇不刪去計有的評論 但是注明那些唱片應該的原始版本
真是有趣...一想到這麼多樂評都栽掉就覺得真是過癮阿
我之前就在網站上看過Hatto演奏的GODOWSKY The Complete Studies on Chopin's Etudes
居然被評為10/10 七十幾歲的老人
怎麼可能~~~~
最後果然是造假阿
列一些他拷貝的版本 哈..
ISAAC ALBÉNIZ
Iberia
Joyce Hatto (piano) --> Jean-Francois Heisser's Erato performance
LEOPOLD GODOWSKY
The Complete Studies on Chopin's Etudes
Joyce Hatto (piano) --> These performances are a conflation, sometimes signifcantly altered as to
timings, of Marc-André Hamelin (Hyperion) and Carlo Grante (Altarus).
WOLFGANG AMADEUS MOZART
The Complete Piano Sonatas
Joyce Hatto (piano) --> from Ingrid Haebler's Mozart cycle on Denon.
MAURICE RAVEL
Complete Piano Works
Joyce Hatto (piano) --> French pianist Roger Muraro,
issued on Universal France's Accord label.
CLAUDE DEBUSSY
Preludes Books 1 & 2
Joyce Hatto (piano) --> These performances evidently should be credited to Izumi Tateno, originally
recorded for Canyon Classics.
FRANZ LISZT
The 12 Transcendental Etudes
Joyce Hatto (piano) --> This disc consists, for the most part (ten of twelve
tracks), of Laszlo Simon's performance of the Etudes on BIS, with one track
taken from Minoru Nogima's Liszt recital on Reference Recordings
OLIVIER MESSIAEN
Vingt Regards Sur L’Enfant-Jésus
Joyce Hatto (piano) -->
Credit for this recording should go to Paul Kim, on Centaur
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 61.224.49.193