Re: [請益] 有關於screamo

[vendock (vendock)]

※ 引述《shortmason (全力出發的好結果)》之銘言：
:    突然想到問題是，screamo的起源是？金屬死腔裡面演變的嗎？
;....
:    screamo就算算成是龐克的分支，關係應該也比較遠了，
:    不過還是想請問一下版上的各位，screamo 的起源和screamo與punk的關係。



i'm a little too lazy to respond to this in chinese, so i will write this in
english. (英文實在是看不懂的大大對不起  =口=)

removing all the timestamps, history, and arguments, the essential relation of
punk music and the modern emo/screamo music can be simplified below:

punk music was invented (rough, self-produced, non-corporated)
-
indie music was invented (basically all other types of music self-produced.
also called "alternative" music)
-
emo/screamo music was invented (a sector of alternative music where emotions
are the topic of lyrics. when done with singing lyrics often described as emo
and when shouted or screamed, often described as screamo)

however, as alternative music grow to be much more popular, a lot of small
record labels start getting bigger or being bought out by large companies.
creating a 矛盾 situation between the music and the original "indie" mindset.



:    繁體中文網頁全部都沒有，英文...起源...是寫成begining嗎？
是 beginning 或 origin

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 192.192.90.211
推 thedeadearth:獨立團加入大廠是不是都因為公司給的錢多又不干涉他
→ thedeadearth:們創作的東西阿
推 vendock:有band說是要讓他的想法傳給更多人,but都會變調 :(
→ vendock:其實幾乎所有被簽的團音都會變超不同
推 MostAlone:給1樓 你可以看看綠天在Woodtock 94講的話
→ MostAlone:再看看他們現在的作品 你就知道主流label的"干涉程度了
推 PunkWhite:那ANTI FLAG呢 感覺他們的批判火力還是在耶@@
推 vendock:樓上沒發現音調&音色的改變嗎? 或是他們在以前所推崇的
→ vendock:純龐克反系統理念現在變成只是對政府發洩的"批判"?
→ vendock:這變化已經好多年了,雖然他們有留存著反戰爭的想法,可是
→ vendock:他們反"旗"所代表的已經完全不同 = =
→ PunkWhite:多謝樓上講解!!!!音色方面還真的有點不一樣了@@
→ vendock:或聽聽bad religion的against the grain 比一下他們近年來
→ vendock:的其他作品,像the empire strikes back