[國中] Is there a book on the desk?

作者qoowahaha (下雨時想起)

看板TeachEnglish

標題[國中] Is there a book on the desk?

時間Tue Jan 13 22:10:37 2009

康軒第一冊第八課的文法 A: Is there a book on the desk? B: _____________. There are two books on the desks. 講義上說只要用"a" 只要有，就要回答Yes 答案是 Yes, there is. 可是和後面的數量不合我的第一個直覺是 No, there is not. 才對請問大家的意見，謝謝!! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 203.67.49.101

推 dunchee:"No...." "Not really..." 01/14 01:06

→ outofdejavu:Are you blind? (無誤...) 01/14 02:26

推 sitifan:Yes, there is. 01/14 08:57

推 SetsunaLeo:二樓好好笑XD 01/15 00:40

→ SetsunaLeo:No, there are two! Are you blind??!! 01/15 00:40

→ SetsunaLeo:我覺得會回答yes，是因為"a"在此不是one的意思 01/15 00:41

→ SetsunaLeo:而是一般概略稱呼可數名詞的單位 01/15 00:41

→ SetsunaLeo:但我覺得題目改is there any book...會比較好 01/15 00:42

推 nioe429:推二樓中肯XD 01/15 02:25

推 sitifan:is there any book..並不會比較好, 請看我的回文 01/15 14:15