Re: [高中] 一題遠東版高中英文想請教大家

[dennistao (英文你老師)]

: 今天在教介係詞加關代時，課本中有一題文法練習題，是這樣寫：
: Fanny: My father decided to close his company.
:        My father and my grandfather had a huge argument over my father's
:        decision.

先不論教學手冊，我的認知是my father decided to close his company和
                          my father's decision為先行詞，不應該重複寫出
                          所以會用關係代名詞代表

於是我們就可以寫出同位語的句型：(也就是非限定用法)
My father decided to close his company, which my father and my grandfather had
a huge argument over.(此時的over又可以搬到which前面，如果大家對關代熟稔的話)

這是我對第一句的理解



: 另外，還有個學生來問了我另一題
: You are saying that everyone should be equal, and this is _____ I disagree.
: A) why
: B) where
: C) what
: D) how

第二題的題目是不是有打錯？或者是我理解錯誤？
這邊第二句可以把他寫成純粹的關係代名詞(who, which等)
就可以寫成：You are saying that everyone should be equal, and
            this is the things which I disagree with.

根據意思可以寫成另兩句：
1.You are saying that everyone should be equal, this is which I disagree with.
2.You are saying that everyone should be equal, and this is what I disagree with.

第一句我確定是那樣，第二句大家再討論看看吧！


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 121.254.86.37
推 eggpie:你好像沒有回答到原po的問題, 然後第二句沒錯
推 eggpie:你另寫的第二句this is which...有問題喔
推 bblyc:我忽然發現第一個題目 應該是where= on which
→ bblyc:因為 disagree on _____ （手殘）
推 eggpie:disagree接on/over 都可以搭配sth.吧
推 rbitmbasitw:想要問一下這邊用限定跟非限定有什麼差別嗎？