Re: [AI. ] Top 6-勵志周

[nopeeking (Down Under)]

[enpu大借小的用一下格式XD]


透過charity來追捧自己的聲勢，我必須要說American Idol腦筋動得很快。

而且做這麼大，真是相當不容易啊。


可是本週選歌怎麼會無聊成這樣子？我在猜可能精力都集中在禮拜三的兩個小時節目吧。

1. Chris - "If I Could Change the World" by Eric Clapton
哎，可惜我只看到做作以及音準的問題，所以他直接被擺進B3 list。

Forgettable performance, sorry.

2. Melinda - "There Will Come a Day" by Faith Hill
No-Neck stepped up! 她是今晚唯一發光體, NO-DOUBT。Melinda, aka No-Neck, but

also, resident pro!!天哪，這次表演讓我從頭發麻到尾, in a good way of course!

自信一來，表演感染力真是強多了！不過VFTW有人建議是說：No Neck, No Idol。

給Melinda fans參考一下:p

3. Blake - "Imagine" by John Lennon
Way too risky, during the performance I just had a flash thought across,
"Does he even own a John Lennon album?"

There is no way he could use his magic in this kinda song. "Did you guys
notice that Blake is gonna win without even trying?" VFTW fans said.

I need some efforts from you, Blake. Sincerity is not the criterion you need
to keep you on stage.

(I've had enough since last week.) But I still root for you, please, I need
something seriously.

4. Lakisha - "I Believe" by Fantasia
到這個階段，LaKliche是被我放在Phil一起評價的。他們倆應該是所謂amateur的代表，
一個是音樂涉獵較低（且似乎未經過音樂訓練）的KiKi，一個是（我認為極有可能）也
沒有經過訓練的Phil。一再地重唱former idols' songs，怎樣都是被人抓來鞭的啊。

而音準問題從沒解決，shouting as always。我挺看好KiKi packing的。:p

5. Phil - "The Change" by Garth Brooks
我還是喜歡吸血鬼的聲音，也不知是否該高興，Phil目前是VFTW的主力支持目標。XD
"We love you even if you can't be exposed to direct sunlight."  XDXDXD
可惜Phil似乎還是少了很玄的一個重點：connection。（I can't feel a thing……）

不過這個空缺就讓VFTW來補足吧。XD


6. Jordin - "You'll Never Walk Alone" by Rodgers & Hammerstein
以往我是很欣賞Jordin的，可是這次我有了其他的想法…

Why shouting is not an issue for Jordin? 這次她的表演高低起伏相當劇烈，
也剛好她的高低起伏的頂點谷點都處理的不好，我甚至認為這首歌是她參賽以來
最糟的一次…。orz


Who will go? Either Chris or KiKi is fine.

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 140.113.56.189
推 enpu:Phil大學好像是修聲樂的 應該算是受過訓練
推 nopeeking:Nooooooooo Waaaaaaaaaaay, 受過訓練還唱成這樣？！
推 nopeeking:本晚最驚嚇orz  居然是修過聲樂的…
推 enpu:He holds a degree in vocal performance from Lee Universit
推 nopeeking:I am too on wiki now. Still in shock. orz
→ nopeeking:Quite a "musical" life he had.
→ ladyluck:Phil的歌聲如果是業餘的我會很驚豔...如果是受過訓練的..
→ ladyluck:會很無言......