作者Sternenlicht (★GoodBye, 礎寧★)
看板AmericanIdol
標題Re: [Ｓ7 ] David Archuleta - David Archuleta
時間Thu Nov 13 23:43:50 2008
※ 引述《Rfed (R費)》之銘言：
: 娛樂週刊給專輯 C+評價，
: 主要是說專輯平板、歌唱沒有熱情。←(這真是他的致命傷～)
Billboard的review也出來了。評價好的嚇人。
Most teen Disney heroes have got nothing on David Archuleta.
The 17-year-old
who was one of the most exciting "American Idol" contenders has one of those
once-in-a-decade pop voices: A silky tenor with a natural melancholy that
makes him a heartbreaker by default. His charming debut exploits that very
quality with some strokes of pop genius, like "Touch My Hand," a temporary
love ballad to the pretty girl in the front row, and "Your Eyes Don't Lie,"
a Jonas Brothers-do-"No Diggity" ditty with a fair amount of crooner slink.
But
Archie is at his best on the bleeders, like piano ballad "To Be With You,"
and "Angels," the Robbie Williams cover he saved from obscurity on "Idol."
These are the kinds of performances meant for arenas. —Kerri Mason
十年一見的聲音.....Wow....
===
然後來看另一個完全相反的評論 XD Rollingstone 的評論。
評價：
★★☆ （笑倒）
On he most recent season of American Idol, David Archuleta was a golden-voiced
koala, too sweet to be sexy. His debut is similarly flavorless: Beautifully
sung but snoozy tunes like "My Hands" never achieve takeoff, and his chaste
voice is a poor match for lovey-dovey lyrics. He only sounds like he's having
a blast on "Don't Let Go," co-written with JC Chasez, which digs into an edgier
melody and trades vocal gymnastics for pure power. At least the disc ends with
a reminder of how Archuleta got here: "Angels," the Robbie Williams cover he
sang on Idol, where he lost to David Cook but won millions of fans
綜觀來看，對 Angels 都是好評不斷。
小弟最厲害的還是 Piano Ballade 啊，以後如果要改走成人路線，
鋼琴芭樂歌是絕對少不了的....再來就看青少年買不買小弟專輯的帳...
（插播：Taylor Swift的專輯一天賣了20萬張.......）
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 59.105.162.155
※ 編輯: Sternenlicht 來自: 59.105.162.155 (11/13 23:51)
推 ladyluck:早說小弟就該唱Angel這種歌才有fu 11/14 01:53
推 sunrio:每次看見滾石的評論都很不以為然.... 11/14 03:21
推 wind750933:泰勒超強^^ 11/14 08:00
推 wind750933:小弟頭髮亂掉了 XD 11/14 12:28
推 hamilton:小弟被叫做golden-voiced koala阿 真妙的稱呼 哈哈~~ 11/14 14:55
→ aides:上面那張是剛比完賽不久的照片啦，好久以前 XD 11/14 16:44
推 anjohn:小弟都變成大弟了… 11/14 16:49
推 aides:還好啦，這幾天上TRL跟Regiis & Kelly都不胖啊 11/14 16:50
推 nopeeking:滾石真是很客氣呢（攤手） 11/14 17:32
→ Sternenlicht:我單純懷疑那半顆星是因為Angels XD 11/14 17:37
推 nopeeking:小板也真是客氣 XD 11/14 17:39
→ Sternenlicht:（喝茶）好說好說 11/14 17:40
→ Sternenlicht:專輯聽了這麼多天，都沒有弟粉出來popo專輯感想耶~ 11/14 17:40
推 nopeeking:我個人認為那半顆星是賞給前面十一首的（被毆飛） 11/14 17:41
→ Sternenlicht:（繼續斟茶） 11/14 17:43