推 Hain:因為喬安娜是個長的像媽媽的女兒..... 05/05 00:20
→ Hain:安東尼慌亂中似乎沒時間懷疑..... 05/05 00:21
推 MidnightBach:安東尼真是天真的大男孩 05/05 00:26
推 MidnightBach:不對 我的意思是說；安東尼怎麼沒有這樣的懷疑 05/05 00:37
→ MidnightBach:並沒有質疑到陶德為何會知道喬安那的外表 05/05 00:37
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------- <
作者: ppr (Sunday) 看板: BROADWAY
標題: Re: Sweeney Todd的bug?
時間: Fri May 5 05:44:33 2006
※ 引述《MidnightBach (午夜巴哈)》之銘言：
: 標題: Sweeney Todd的bug?
: 時間: Fri May 5 00:17:16 2006
:
: Sweeney Todd有個地方看了很奇怪
:
: 就是安東尼找陶德商量救喬安那的事時
:
: 安東尼不會覺得很奇怪嗎 明明陶德就沒看過喬安那
:
: 怎麼會比安東尼更了解喬安那的髮色跟外表呢？
:
: Bug乎？
:
: --
: ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
: ◆ From: 61.59.224.221
: 推 Hain:因為喬安娜是個長的像媽媽的女兒..... 05/05 00:20
: → Hain:安東尼慌亂中似乎沒時間懷疑..... 05/05 00:21
: 推 MidnightBach:安東尼真是天真的大男孩 05/05 00:26
: 推 MidnightBach:不對 我的意思是說；安東尼怎麼沒有這樣的懷疑 05/05 00:37
: → MidnightBach:並沒有質疑到陶德為何會知道喬安那的外表 05/05 00:37
沒啊，Todd沒有透露他知道Joanna的髮色與外表。他只有教Anthony偽裝成假髮製造師
的一些行話而已。
TODD (Excitedly, to ANTHONY) : We will write a letter to this Mr. Fogg
offering the highest price for hair the exact shade of Johanna's
— which I trust you know?
(P.S.這裡Todd可沒有說Johanna到底是什麼髮色歐～他畢竟應該不知道。
反倒是Todd像是在跟Anthony套話。 which I trust you know這句是重點）
ANTHONY: Yellow.
TODD: Not exact enough. I must make you a credible wigmaker — and quickly.
(Sings)
There's tawny and there's golden saffron,
There's flaxen and there's blonde .. .
(Speaks)
Repeat that. Repeat that!
這裡就是Todd教Anthony精確形容髮色的字，後面還有形容髮質等等的，
都是Todd教導Anthony成為一個credible wigmaker的過程而已，沒提到Johanna
長得怎樣或是甚麼髮色。
ANTHONY: Yes, Mr. TODD.
TODD: Well?
ANTHONY:
There's tawny and there's golden saffron,
There's flaxen and there's blonde ...
TODD: Good.
(Sings)
There's coarse and fine,
There's straight and curly, ANTHONY:
There's gray, there's white. There's coarse and fine,
There's ash, there's pearly. There's straight and curly,
There's corn-yellow There's gray, there's white,
Buff and ochre and There's ash, there's pearly,
Straw and apricot. .. There's corn-yellow ...
=========Sweeney Sweeney Sweeney Sweeney Sweeney /尖叫/============
後來Anthony到瘋人院拯救Johanna的過程：
(ANTHONY has been looking around and has spotted JOHANNA)
ANTHONY: This one here has hair the shade I seek.
FOGG: Poor child. She needs so much correction. She sings all day and night an
d leaves the other inmates sleepless. (He goes to JOHANNA and tugs her, indign
antly struggling, across the floor toward ANTHONY, by the hair)
=========Sweeney Sweeney Sweeney Sweeney Sweeney /尖叫/============
最後Johanna闖入Todd的理髮店，目擊了他的行徑後從箱子裡出來，
Todd驚嚇中也差點殺掉Johanna，更證實了Todd並不清楚Johanna長
得什麼樣。（雖然Johanna當時易裝，但是如果你覺得Todd知道Johanna
的長相，怎麼會認不出來呢？）
也因此結論應該就是：Todd根本就沒有具體形容過Johanna的髮色跟長相，
照劇本來說他也應該完全不知道她長什麼樣。自然Anthony也沒東西好懷疑。
--
你應該是在問這一段吧？ >////<
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 59.104.12.195
※ 編輯: ppr 來自: 59.104.12.195 (05/05 05:59)
推 MidnightBach:姐姐好厲害喔 (抱抱) 05/05 23:36
推 MidnightBach:再推尖叫分隔線 好有臨場感 (剛剛才發現到 XD) 05/06 01:39