[外電] ESPN Baseball tonight CY chat

[xiemark (aisinjuro)]

http://proxy.espn.go.com/chat/chatESPN?event_id=15261

Chat during Baseball Tonight


Welcome to The Show! On Monday, we've got a special chat for you, when
we'll come at you live during ESPN's Baseball Tonight! We'll be chatting
while Karl Ravech, John Kruk, Steve Phillips and the rest of the gang
are bringing you all the latest news and notes from around the diamonds.

Your comments from the chat will fill an entire segment on Baseball
Tonight called "Chatter Up!" Say it here and it just might end up on
your TV!

Join us during the 9:30 p.m. ET Baseball Tonight on Monday and YOU,
SportsNation, will be the stars of the show!

Question: Who is your AL Cy Young favorite?

David (Virginia): My AL Cy Young favorite is Kelvim Escobar. He's got a
3.04 ERA and 16 wins. Wow!

Trevor (Mesa, AZ): It's gotta be C.C. Sabathia. He beats Santana every
time they face each other, and he's been ridiculous at the end of the
season. He has not given up more than 2 earned runs in a start since
July 19. Phenomenal!

Justin (NY, NY): Clearly I am biased, but my pick is Wang. This,
however, is assuming he stays course and leads the league in wins, and
can lower his ERA from around 3.6 to the lower 3's. Although not a
strikeout pitcher by any means, Wang is as good a ground-ball pitcher as
there is. It is rare that teams can rally for more than 2 or 3 runs
against him in any one inning. Infact, the damage against him almost
always occurs in one single inning, when groundballs happen to find
holes in the infield consecutively.

Sean (Cleveland): The Cy Young is Sabathia's to lose.

Aaron (St. Louis): Since Cy Young goes to the best pitcher and not "most
valuable" pitcher, I would have to say Dan Haren is the AL Cy Young. His
numbers are great and his quality start percentage is through the roof.

Steve (Ohio): Biased, but it has to be C.C. Sabathia. Leads the leauge
in IP, top five in ERA, Wins, WHIP, total strikeouts, and most
"advanced" metrics as well. In a very close race, C.C.'s IP advantage
carries him to the top.

BK: Kelvim Escobar has to get a longer look. On a staff where he is
"technically" the #2 guy he places in the top in almost every major
pitching cateogry. This is a guy who has actually be historically a very
good pitcher but, with comical run support.

Lane (Kukuihaele, HI): Erik Bedard has done more with less. He starts a
game knowing his offense is pathetic and if he gives up only one run
there's a good chance he might lose the game. If he's in a Yankee, Red
Sox, or Indian uniform then he's the 2007 Cy Young Award winner.

Brady (Colorado): Josh Becket, no question. Tied for the league in wins,
7th in ERA, has the least runs allowed, only to be tied with the
Cardinals failure Anthony Reyes, who has 79 less innings pitched than
Becket. Becket for AL CY YOUNG!

Anthony (Beaufort,SC) : Im going with Erik Bedard. He has been nearly
perfect playing on a very bad and slumping O's ball club.

Avi (Atlanta): I have to go with CC Sabathia. The Indians would not be
in the same position without his Cy worthy performace. He is a top
leader in strike outs, wins and has a great ERA.

Zach (Mount Vernon, IN): It's got to be Sabathia. He beats the so called
''best pitcher in the majors'' in Johan Santana almost every time they
face off. The fact that he is on a winning club helps his case too.

Joe(Brooklyn,NY): I have to go with Justin Verlander on this one. With
Kenny Rogers injured and Jeremy Bonderman struggling, he really has
stepped up and put up some numbers. And he has put up a respectable 16-5
record.

Lane (Kukuihaele, HI): Erik Bedard doesn't usually have the luxury of
pitching with a 3 or 4 run lead. He doesn't have a great defense behind
him. Plus the O's relief pitching belong in Triple A.

Aaron (Jessup, Pa.): Is everyone forgetting about THE best pitcher in
baseball, Johan Santana? His numbers beat every pitcher in the AL, and
if he pitched in the NL, it would be down right scary. People are
treating the CY Young like the MVP. It's about the best pitcher, not
who's most valuable. Although without Johan, Minnesota would be basement
dwellers.

Mike (Arlington, VA): Wang is clearly the CY Young.. and just think if
he was healthy to start the season

Lane (Kukuihaele, HI): Bedard has better numbers than Santana except for
wins. Bedard's numbers are comparable to every pitcher. It's not his
fault he plays on the worst team of all the Cy Young contenders. It's
too bad he'll get overlooked by most of the voters. He's already
overlooked by the fans of Sportsnation...

Rob, Chicago: Its all about CC Sabathia here. 17 wins, 3.15 ERA, 185 Ks,
his stuff is absolutely filthy and his club definitely wouldn't be the
same without him. He's a workhorse!

Zach (Mount Vernon,IN): It's got to be Sabathia. He beats the so called
''best pitcher in the majors'' in Johan Santana almost every time they
face off. The fact that he is on a winning club helps his case too.

Ricardo ( Salinas, CA): At first i had to go with my man Dan Haren, but
after a while, he isn't exactly the toghest pitcher on the block
anymore... It's all about C.C. Sabathia because he's got 17 wins, the
3.15 ERA, and the 185 k's, so if that doesn't make a good pitcher I dont
know what does.

Willie (rocky mount, N.C.): Wang!! Not a dominate Strike out pitcher,
but thats not what pitching is about, he is solid every start, even when
thr yanks stunk he pitched well and kept them floating, now look they
are leading the wild card, he deserves alot of credit for that.

realbbbb (FLA): anyone who says that "Wang is clearly the Cy Young" has
never heard of a thing called Run Support. Put Wang on the Indians or
Angels and he doesn't come close to 18 wins. Would Wang still be Cy
Young with 14-15 wins. Heck no.

Ricardo ( Salinas, CA): Has to be C.C. Sabathia with the 3.15 ERA, the
185 K's, and the 17 wins. If that doesn't scream Cy Young, I don't know
what does.

Joe Monte (Pacific Beach): CC is the frontrunner right now w/ 220
innings, which is very important in the modern era of baseball. If Wang
beats Beckett on Saturday, I give Wang the nod over Beckett in the CY
award running. Don't forget Wang only had two starts in April coming off
injury.

Justin (Evansville, IN): Josh Beckett has been an exemplar of
consistency (18 W, 8.57 K/9, 3.27 ERA) for the best team in baseball.
How can you argue against those credentials?

Lane (Kukuihaele, HI): Bedard!! A dominant Strike out pitcher, but
that's not what pitching is about, he is solid every start, and the O's
stink, he deserves a lot of credit for putting fans in the seats in
Baltimore. Touche Wille (rocky mount, N.C.)

Joey,San Diego: Chien Ming Wang. He doesn't have a lot of strikeouts,
but that's because it isn't his game. He has as many wins as anyone and
an excellent sinker that can get anyone to ground out.

Philip (Williston, ND): C.C. Sabathia, aka the work horse, is the guy,
with 4 complete games (2nd in AL), a 3.15 era and 17 wins, how can you
go any other way. Oh, and his team is up 5 1/2 over the Tigers.

SportsNation Buzzmaster: (10:41 PM ET ) Thanks for another great edition
of Chatter Up! We'll do this again next week!



--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 211.23.177.142
※ xiemark:轉錄至看板 MLB                                          09/14 17:57
推 cardfat:good 其實去年BBWAA投給王就不是很計較王的low-k了
→ cardfat:Goldman之前的文章也有類似的呈述
推 kingasus:其實有實際的成績大家都看得到....那些記者有他們的看法
推 cardfat:或許今年21W/6L ERA3.5 SO="99" 會更有魅力 XDDDD
推 tubryan:C.C. 9票, Wang 4票, Becket和Bedard 2票, 其他都只有1票!
推 windspir:Wang應該是三票喔,有一個記者好像是在批他= =
推 ying11027:Wang 3票 看起來 CC壓倒性獲勝XDDDD
推 jesuiskks:王有四票 另外有一個投給C.C的說 若王禮拜六擊敗Becketꨠ
→ jesuiskks:他覺得王比Becket更有機會拿cy 然後有一個人沒有說他支ꐠ
→ jesuiskks:持誰 只有對認為王有機會拿cy的人說 王很多的火力支援
→ jesuiskks:說什麼如果王在天使或印地安人 18勝對他可能有點遠
推 ZzzBa:這個週末是關鍵阿, 天阿好緊張....贏的話可能跟CC五五波
推 ying11027:55波？我沒這麼樂觀耶, 除非Sabathia那場投不好
→ ying11027:用這篇來看 Sabathia是穩得CY的，其他人都有一段距離
推 ZzzBa:哈,不然你的預測咧?只會批別人,how about your opinion?
→ ZzzBa:沒關係阿,就看最後誰比較準:)
推 ying11027:我沒有批你阿，不要誤解我Orz
推 shyshy:Z先生你的批點就低耶
推 Annrod:星期日贏的話，我相信印象分數應該會增加不少