[新聞] 滾石評論"NMT"

[forever36 (演)]

Christina Aguilera Gets Dirty Again

Please, no cracks about how when Aguilera says she's "Not Myself Tonight,"
she sounds like Lady Gaga instead. This electro-cheese club banger might be
her best dance track since "Genie In A Bottle." Producer Polow Da Don
piles on plush Euro-disco synth flourishes while Aguilera moans,
"That feels good, I needed that.
" Aguilera has never had much luck with disco--her voice is
too fussy and busy to function as a dance-floor sound effect--but
on this track, she melds her pipes with synths. The best moment hits
at the two minute mark, when her voice flickers on the word "toni-i-i-ight,
" turning into a strobe-light flash.
This song was obviously designed to cold-rock bachelorette parties,
so get set to hear it the next time some blitzed bridesmaid spills
her Disaronno-and-Sprite on you.

3/5 stars

算是還OK的評論,但是還是有談到GAGA
唉…連專業樂評都愛拿來談論

評論者Rob Sheffield ,過去一向對Xtina不太友善!

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 115.83.189.70
推 mrhalliwell:我覺得跟gaga聲音不像 gaga的更重一點 x的比較沙一點
→ mrhalliwell:我也很愛gaga   但覺得聲音魅力  Xtina真的比較好
推 laipipi:覺得很怪，再怎麼也應該說GAGA聲音向他比較正常
→ laipipi:畢竟他聲音一直都是這樣，沒有因為GAGA而變聲阿
→ laipipi:沒有要攻擊GAGA 我也是他的粉絲
推 tenoe:Who is Rob Sheffield? I don't know her.
推 haagis:gaga的聲音在唱到低沉的時候有xtina的感覺,但是gaga的聲音
→ haagis:比較會讓我聯想到gwen(在ga剛出道時)不過愛xtina>gwen>gaga
推 shalomlee:覺得GAGA聲音有時像XTINA 而不是XTINA聲音像GAGA
→ shalomlee:那些評論的會這樣說不過就是GAGA大紅的時候小克沒發片
→ shalomlee:現在要發片了歌曲剛好有現在潮流的電音元素 而二人音質
→ shalomlee:相似 這樣被拿來批評說像GAGA不公平
推 as9595:我覺得小克比較會唱!!  GAGA有唱過高音嘛!??
推 StarShooting:樓上，Gaga應該還是有唱過高音啦! 但小克唱功更好!!!
推 moo885588:根本不像啊 這些人到底有完沒完 什麼事都要扯到嘎嘎是怎
→ moo885588:樣= =? 受不鳥!!!
推 panism:老實說 我自己聽GAGA的歌很容易膩
推 Keiwu:其實GAGA也滿強的~有時音質滿像XTINA的~聲音更復古些~~
→ Keiwu:XTINA唱藍調FU是特強~高音比的話個人認為XTINA較優啦~~~
→ Keiwu:她們二個我都很愛~~GAGA歌其實比較不耐聽~且又愛用電音版
→ Keiwu:但是我確實是有聽到GAGA的acoustic版本很不錯聽的~~~
→ Keiwu:我想會比較不好聽可能是編曲方式有關~~但她的歌確實較前衛
→ Keiwu:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3R3KqrJAI4&feature=playe
→ Keiwu:可以聽聽~gaga的音樂性也是非常好的~~但實在不愛電音就是~~
推 chspfang:我喜歡telephone 其他..還好囧 mv很好看
推 panism:gaga即興真的好強喔 但我心中第一還是xtina欸
推 hikkiyo:哇靠那即興狗仔好好聽!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
→ moo885588:嘎嘎也是個假白人XD