兩大權威業界媒體的評論
Hollywood Reporter http://tinyurl.com/yk68s5
Zellweger tries to make up for these deficiencies with a performance that
bubbles over with coy mannerisms, squinty-eyed grimaces and outlandish
"period" precision in her studied gestures. The actress has been playing
Brits for so long that the accent is no bother, but a bit of her native Texas
creeps into the exaggerated affectations. In a contemporary movie, you would
assume such a character is on drugs.
The true Brits fare better. Ewan McGregor strikes the right balance between
turn-of-the-20th century formality and turn-of-the-21th century commentary,
showing you the man beneath the manners in Norman Warne, Beatrix's publisher
and the love of her life. Same for Emily Watson as Norman's sister, Millie,
who becomes Beatrix's great confidante. Hers is a character Jane Austin would
willingly claim as her own. Watson turns Millie into a blazing hearth, a
woman who radiates warmth and congeniality. The other British actors perform
the minor roles with the usual aplomb.
Variety
http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117932337.html?categoryid=31&cs=1
Zellweger's Beatrix is hard to warm to, which is made more difficult by the
actor's visible efforts to play as British as possible. Paired with both an
easy, velvety McGregor -- who has rarely appeared so pleasant -- and the
firecracker Watson, Zellweger looks considerably outmatched and ever so
strained. Casting aims for close physical resemblance to actual figures, but
this is submerged by the supporting thesps' fine work, including Matyelok
Gibbs as Beatrix's comically doddering chaperon.
iFilm上面有三個電影片段
"First Man" http://www.ifilm.com/video/2807111 --> 有可愛鵝媽媽
"First Book" http://www.ifilm.com/video/2807111
--> 為何我越看越覺得Renee說那一段
"In other words, you have no experience whatsoever..."的神情
很像DWL最後她在辦公室裡訓Cather Block的樣子啊 o_O
"Museum" http://www.ifilm.com/video/2807113?loomia_si=1
--> 有神奇的Emily Watson
還有不知是否我錯覺，總覺得他們放的預告片又跟我看過的不大一樣....
http://www.ifilm.com/video/2802106
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 218.166.80.62