[語文] GWD-TN-20 Q17

[libys (libys)]

TN20-17 (GWD30-Q17)

By the same techniques used for genetically enhancing plants, making them
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
disease- or pest-resistant, researchers have been able to increase the amount
of protein in potatoes, sweet potatoes, and tobacco.

A)By the same techniques used for genetically enhancing plants,making them
B)With the same techniques to genetically enhance plants, so that they are
C)Employing the same techniques used to genetically enhance plants so that they
  are
D)Employing the same techniques to genetically enhance plants, which makes them
E)Employing the same techniques for genetically enhancing plants that make them


答案不確定是哪一個，
TN的答案是B，ChaseDream上蠻多討論說是E，兩年多前補習時老師說是D
想請大家一起來討論，謝謝。

列出ChaseDream上的部分討論內容

C) employ 和 use 的意思重複，so that用法奇怪
D) which和them的指代問題，ChaseDream上說意思很不清楚，但是補習班老師說非限定用
   法的關係代名詞指前一句話，在這裡which是指Employing....plants，而them是指
   plants
E) 補習班老師說應該用to engance，但是ChaseDream上認為for enhancing限定性修釋
   techniques，在這裡比to enhance好，而that是指techniques

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 218.167.99.132
→ jennes:同意(D),(B)與(C)的they指代不清
→ jennes:(E)that關代修飾plant,改變句意
→ jennes:以上個人意見請參考，若有錯誤歡迎指正嚕
推 patricia331:可是  (D)which很少可以指代一整個句子的吧?
→ jennes:有挖 OG#43 which 指一整件事喔(只是題目把which改成分詞)
推 patricia331:J大說的是 bringing那題嘛?
→ jennes:是阿 不過gmat中which以非限定用法修飾句子的還真少
推 patricia331:我覺得那題不是用which改成分詞耶 是用伴隨副詞的概念
→ jennes:若當伴隨副詞，bringing主詞變成five fledging sea eagles
→ jennes:整句話的意思就會變得很奇怪喔 小海鷗不會帶回34隻成鳥阿~
→ jennes:這樣句意就會很奇怪, 因為小海鷗不會帶回34隻成鳥阿~~
→ jennes:而且當伴隨副,選項(E)就可以選嚕..但OG解釋,主詞不合邏輯
推 patricia331:謝謝J大