推 Jacktang:............................ 61.216.115.175 06/16 23:11
推 Ahshiung:喔耶!!!!! 220.132.198.68 06/16 23:11
→ librann:囧 59.115.79.120 06/16 23:11
推 Dunlop:............................ 59.121.123.168 06/16 23:11
推 shoese:亂七八糟122.126.132.113 06/16 23:11
推 Tzylu:......................................... 125.232.3.127 06/16 23:11
→ hillku:唉... 123.194.153.25 06/16 23:12
推 CharmedP3:YA~~~ 211.74.176.233 06/16 23:12
→ DeepRiver226:囧 61.217.163.192 06/16 23:12
推 JPMontoya:G奶~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 59.113.181.17 06/16 23:12
推 h122478:@@ 220.131.114.99 06/16 23:12
推 kofo:..... 59.116.168.44 06/16 23:12
推 ttk620:... 220.229.82.96 06/16 23:11
推 abenatsuo:果然不出所料220.142.226.170 06/16 23:11
推 tonytsai88:果然是Jolin~ 220.132.186.59 06/16 23:11
推 cohone:...................................... 218.167.75.183 06/16 23:12
推 CaoPi:OH NO218.174.197.109 06/16 23:12
→ QoiiwWe:阿咩..penny..218.170.233.194 06/16 23:12
推 whatc21:......... 61.230.31.180 06/16 23:12
推 dichia:penny啊啊啊 Orz 59.105.93.141 06/16 23:12
→ bluemoonss:最不想要Jolin221.169.148.141 06/16 23:11
推 nanako24:ㄜ................ 59.115.221.193 06/16 23:12
推 motel:我的阿妹.....我不相信..... 59.117.184.24 06/16 23:11
推 ilangrace:..................................... 124.8.237.58 06/16 23:12
推 phantomwind:.................. 59.117.97.149 06/16 23:12
→ morning21:囧 219.81.231.116 06/16 23:12
推 ClavierBoy:好開心喔 真棒 61.62.110.72 06/16 23:12
推 hsin0531:痾 125.225.80.122 06/16 23:12
→ icat:冏125.230.127.169 06/16 23:12
推 carolbass198:我好想需ˊˋ 220.142.30.90 06/16 23:12
推 shchin:囧 211.76.254.18 06/16 23:12
推 pamper:........................................140.112.204.199 06/16 23:12
推 rede:.....218.165.192.224 06/16 23:12
推 ncaa8702:暴冷 124.8.141.201 06/16 23:12
推 goro18:..................................... 59.105.199.103 06/16 23:12
推 vicfan0609:1010101010 218.168.41.84 06/16 23:12
推 maydaymilk:.................................... 61.229.123.158 06/16 23:12
推 libra13:囧122.123.131.208 06/16 23:12
推 toba:不小心罵出來了218.165.129.217 06/16 23:12
推 yamie0204:.............................. 59.116.179.240 06/16 23:12
推 popobbs:.......... 59.116.6.102 06/16 23:12
推 candicesm:唉!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!218.171.169.224 06/16 23:11
推 MrEugene:我....我.....恭喜! 61.228.132.118 06/16 23:12
推 kimuranene:傻 219.91.65.57 06/16 23:12
→ kassy1112:="=............. 219.80.138.204 06/16 23:12
→ Rikki017:囧140.117.190.133 06/16 23:12
推 hythyt:............. 61.229.210.251 06/16 23:12
推 boringnn:囧另 61.66.53.124 06/16 23:12
→ mengtang:亂七八糟125.232.208.219 06/16 23:12
推 johnnyjaiu:G奶大獲全勝！220.134.146.216 06/16 23:12
推 jack555:金害阿 220.131.46.235 06/16 23:12
推 mayday7969:....................................125.228.124.142 06/16 23:12
推 jerry0621:...................................125.232.102.142 06/16 23:12
推 salul:... 61.228.123.75 06/16 23:12
推 vitzou:靠 真的是蔡依林 張惠妹呢呢呢呢呢呢呢呢呢220.139.133.247 06/16 23:12
→ playoffmogi:囧 218.160.37.233 06/16 23:12
推 smallken0410:水唷! 59.105.40.47 06/16 23:12
推 mam:............. 61.230.21.159 06/16 23:12
推 kirstyasin:想噓123.192.150.102 06/16 23:12
推 hugoweng:.............. 211.74.4.97 06/16 23:12
推 mosquito3467:.............= = 125.229.37.177 06/16 23:12
推 timiyuki:我想噓 122.126.43.199 06/16 23:12
→ calculus9:恩..... 140.116.132.18 06/16 23:12
推 wakeyo:從頭到尾都在捧她 送錢就有獎122.126.101.131 06/16 23:12
推 jackshyu:我@@ 220.132.96.209 06/16 23:12
推 jiazha:阿妹...penny ......220.137.200.186 06/16 23:12
推 lakers1031:............................. 122.126.42.190 06/16 23:12
推 mieng:廣告一直放 放到得獎 XD220.135.177.197 06/16 23:12
→ Aliang:又見G奶晃啊晃！ 219.68.138.179 06/16 23:12
推 freaky0908:囧臨了....122.124.108.192 06/16 23:12
推 Arefishing:果然是G乃＝ ＝ 218.162.75.40 06/16 23:12
推 izod:這一面經典 囧 220.135.206.7 06/16 23:12
推 willyforu:冏 爛死了140.112.239.147 06/16 23:12
推 ilikegeorge:爽爽爽203.121.236.201 06/16 23:12
推 noviea1017:= = 220.142.203.31 06/16 23:12
→ kirkkirkkk:爆冷 125.225.118.88 06/16 23:12
推 iceskycoldly:呃................................125.225.174.118 06/16 23:12
→ guanghagrid:我也罵髒話了 ＝ ＝ 61.228.81.207 06/16 23:12
推 rc2skywalker:囧\ 218.170.119.83 06/16 23:12
推 khhra:囧 61.62.242.166 06/16 23:12
推 happy0321:我要快樂......... 218.174.187.3 06/16 23:12
→ Tzylu:阿妹要哭了 人氣等於最佳歌手 125.232.3.127 06/16 23:12
推 thjyrsj:不意外 123.193.142.63 06/16 23:12
推 keysoon:............................ 59.127.2.101 06/16 23:12
→ yehlieh:囧123.193.198.249 06/16 23:12
→ chimd:恭喜！她很努力！ 140.112.193.87 06/16 23:12
推 coco100:Jolin萬歲 125.229.107.93 06/16 23:12
推 h321123aa:............恭喜.......... 61.229.227.106 06/16 23:12
推 just8811:真的囧令了 140.124.60.192 06/16 23:12
推 light0:........................................ 61.217.219.238 06/16 23:12
推 cometrue50:Angela............................ 218.175.33.31 06/16 23:12
推 euph:開心!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 61.228.121.117 06/16 23:12
推 kirakirei:阿妹這張很好聽耶>"< 218.171.60.35 06/16 23:12
推 kimi0121:根本是亂選嘛125.229.132.141 06/16 23:12
推 happybama:果然…………我的penny 218.175.66.211 06/16 23:12
推 thebackshade:關電視218.162.206.209 06/16 23:12
推 ha0118:做弊啦....為啥是炸蝦啊 218.164.36.249 06/16 23:12
推 Toxiccc:還蠻高興耶 他很努力 進步非常多 218.172.99.231 06/16 23:12
推 rockyue:FINALLY 220.142.3.6 06/16 23:12
推 chupachuys:拜託來個人把我打醒~~~我一定是在作夢 124.8.129.97 06/16 23:12
推 chia12087:啊！！！！ 59.112.190.65 06/16 23:12
→ mengtang:真想噓125.232.208.219 06/16 23:12
推 marcchoutw:...........是女歌手不是女舞者耶.. 218.167.173.37 06/16 23:12
→ lapinyaya:超想罵的!!!!!是怎樣218.167.229.188 06/16 23:12
→ vitzou:...........................220.139.133.247 06/16 23:12
推 ashew:................................. 59.116.141.99 06/16 23:12
推 Dasein:可以罵髒話嗎? 218.166.56.66 06/16 23:12
推 cocola:........................................ 218.167.11.199 06/16 23:12
推 ialian:恭喜 實至名歸 218.169.231.51 06/16 23:12
推 rainman:為何不是阿妹>"<218.166.107.114 06/16 23:12
推 joyjcc:囧囧囧!!!!!!!!!!! 218.166.96.133 06/16 23:12
→ henie:囧 61.229.44.228 06/16 23:12
推 rosemary:恭喜！她很努力！ 61.217.217.61 06/16 23:12
推 gn02993995:ipenny 61.225.53.17 06/16 23:12
推 RedBull:人造G奶 61.216.48.91 06/16 23:12
推 charking:penny阿.......林阿罵咧.... 61.217.160.161 06/16 23:12
→ candicesm:捧的太誇張218.171.169.224 06/16 23:12
推 interplay:她真的很努力！恭喜！ 59.104.16.113 06/16 23:12
→ kassy1112:連她自己都不相信自己會得..ˋ(′_‵||) 219.80.138.204 06/16 23:12
→ khhra:今年真的很囧 囧囧囧 61.62.242.166 06/16 23:12
推 pink0011:囧囧 219.52.44.79 06/16 23:12
推 i99:..........125.231.148.123 06/16 23:13
推 chenhana:恭喜恭喜140.112.214.148 06/16 23:13
→ bluemoonss:覺得誰得都很好，就是不想蔡依林得...221.169.148.141 06/16 23:12
推 flyhigher:冏...............218.170.192.109 06/16 23:12
→ maydaymilk:一頭亂髮+塑膠布 61.229.123.158 06/16 23:12
→ Dunlop:努力去拿最佳努力獎 59.121.123.168 06/16 23:13
推 frederique:當場罵出來~ 59.112.23.86 06/16 23:13
→ saiyumu:.......................................218.175.171.118 06/16 23:13
推 unclelan:SHIT... 女歌手... 59.115.218.207 06/16 23:13
推 jackkiller:爆 218.167.35.141 06/16 23:13
推 popstars:靠！！！我不看啦 想雜電視 59.112.164.93 06/16 23:13
推 lovecmgirls:爽~~!!!! 59.105.8.218 06/16 23:13
推 JANYUJEN:爆冷門阿....penny....218.175.184.211 06/16 23:13
推 EthanShy:爆 134.208.33.213 06/16 23:13
推 grimmp57796:唉= =想罵髒話 219.87.12.246 06/16 23:13
→ lapinyaya:怎樣都不是他啊!!!!! 其他人都可以接受218.167.229.188 06/16 23:13
推 Nickjessie:........................220.140.225.245 06/16 23:13
推 Vataeli:...........爆冷門 61.228.32.250 06/16 23:13
→ DeepRiver226:剛剛才在說非張即戴，若是蔡就很微妙 61.217.163.192 06/16 23:12
推 bobson808:鄉民都有給他努力的動力= = 59.115.239.96 06/16 23:13
推 tglove:就知道是她..為什麼不是阿妹不是Penny 61.229.116.220 06/16 23:13
推 queeny:我也覺得他很努力 恭喜~^^ 61.230.132.227 06/16 23:13
→ kimi0121:因為是G奶嗎125.229.132.141 06/16 23:13
推 NiinnO:靠.................................. 124.8.130.88 06/16 23:13
推 skyhighsky:不想接受125.233.208.245 06/16 23:13
推 jeansjean:我狂罵.... 61.62.123.33 06/16 23:13
→ orangel:這是整個頒獎最不以為然的一個獎 220.141.9.57 06/16 23:13
推 rockido:爽220.129.109.204 06/16 23:13
→ will19820920:什麼鬼東西 218.160.178.92 06/16 23:13
推 iris1028:...我要阿妹 140.130.198.11 06/16 23:13
推 pocotin:我罵了一聲髒話 = = 61.231.192.28 06/16 23:13
推 F5488:罵出來+1..........穿那啥鬼樣子...噁 125.232.195.13 06/16 23:13
推 cdboxmin:還好不是阿妹 61.224.30.245 06/16 23:13
→ light0:努力不等於好聽 61.217.219.238 06/16 23:13
→ ashew:輸給奶= = 59.116.141.99 06/16 23:13
→ saiyumu:當場罵出來 +1218.175.171.118 06/16 23:14
推 pililinjoy:我的阿妹呢???????? 218.162.216.57 06/16 23:13
推 sydg:PENNYYYYYYYY210.192.176.224 06/16 23:14
推 chairlechiu:張惠妹／我要快樂 61.231.18.236 06/16 23:14
推 lanyiling:為甚麼是她 ........... ???? 123.194.81.109 06/16 23:13
推 ALLEN2:嘖嘖 122.124.6.153 06/16 23:14
推 jeiwu:蔡依林...真的不怎麼會唱 220.133.11.211 06/16 23:14
推 babymilkiss:爛死了!什麼鬼阿念經也能得獎??? 61.230.17.160 06/16 23:14
推 shuenren:...................................... 140.111.77.129 06/16 23:14
推 harlemk416:碼的！為什麼是他阿.... 59.124.208.66 06/16 23:14
推 dickyman:呃 論唱功 她差林憶蓮和阿妹一截吧... 61.229.116.140 06/16 23:14
推 Karls:靠腰...Penny...>"< 218.160.59.231 06/16 23:14
推 littlepoll:.............................123.193.186.167 06/16 23:14
推 puden:可以說穿這樣身材真的很怪嗎?? 210.66.19.33 06/16 23:14
推 ycch:我猜張韶涵說 其實是自己支持啦 哈哈 218.170.136.80 06/16 23:14
推 KingInTea:蔡依林／舞孃／科藝百代股份有限公司 61.228.89.190 06/16 23:14
→ jeiwu:蔡依林...真的不怎麼會唱 220.133.11.211 06/16 23:14
推 efb: 我要快樂 219.81.166.221 06/16 23:14
推 kassy1112:我的阿妹....JOLIN拿獎的點到底在那??? 219.80.138.204 06/16 23:14
推 eason1004:她是很努力啦，可是要拿女演唱人還早吧 219.91.77.224 06/16 23:14
→ lanyiling:我的林憶蓮... >< 123.194.81.109 06/16 23:14
推 sasha1019:阿～～不是阿妹 218.175.86.56 06/16 23:14
推 Michaelpipen:怒了～～阿妹咧????? 61.231.48.149 06/16 23:15
推 qmei:很開心耶 60.250.197.76 06/16 23:15
推 anneann:她是最沒有資格得的人218.168.213.225 06/16 23:15
推 pigs:雖然很努力...但歌聲真的還欠佳140.123.212.204 06/16 23:15
推 fatfatman:台灣真悲哀 這種也可以拿音樂獎122.124.104.225 06/16 23:15
推 VGA:@@扯.應該要是阿妹吧... 218.165.125.66 06/16 23:15
推 koinic:輪不到他吧 = =218.171.163.157 06/16 23:15
推 knifegunblue:囧140.116.175.231 06/16 23:15
推 oboe:阿妹..................219.143.147.143 06/16 23:15
推 taapple:恭喜！ 61.230.33.196 06/16 23:15
推 stephaniexu:唉...為什麼不是阿妹阿.....><125.231.147.232 06/16 23:15
推 chitakudo:什麼金曲獎 爛死...218.168.143.243 06/16 23:15
推 UJhsiao:努力看得見 得獎實至名歸220.140.233.115 06/16 23:15
推 tver:...............整晚最莫名其妙的獎 125.228.94.210 06/16 23:15
推 candicesm:唱功也是他最.....218.171.169.224 06/16 23:15
推 superTOFU:一整個很多髒話... 220.129.76.99 06/16 23:15
推 lapinyaya:為什麼不是阿妹... TwT 超想哭的.....218.167.229.188 06/16 23:15
推 ipien:囧....把阿妹置於何處阿 125.229.84.227 06/16 23:15
推 chimd:他歌聲其實還不錯 140.112.193.87 06/16 23:16
→ anneann:阿妹阿妹阿妹!!! 為什麼不是阿妹???218.168.213.225 06/16 23:15
推 Dola1003:penny等很久了耶 還等不到>"< 61.230.176.220 06/16 23:16
推 eiephant:阿妹啦..哎約.. 203.70.120.148 06/16 23:15
→ ailesMia:我要阿妹或PENNYˊˋ123.240.213.101 06/16 23:16
推 rainman:推去拿最佳努力獎 我要快樂啦218.166.107.114 06/16 23:16
推 stevenharry:沒眼睛的評審 一屆比一屆差218.175.175.203 06/16 23:16
推 SugerBoy:我要吐了........ 59.127.166.233 06/16 23:16
推 CaoPi:QQ218.174.197.109 06/16 23:16
→ anneann:真的罵出髒話來了 搞什麼東西!!!218.168.213.225 06/16 23:16
推 di3xyo0z:.....penny ... 140.127.57.39 06/16 23:16
推 wanfu:她竟然能得獎，荒謬 130.83.236.11 06/16 23:15
→ lapinyaya:她很努力..可是唱的相對蠻弱的....218.167.229.188 06/16 23:16
推 phay:我要阿妹!!我要快樂!!評審搞什麼阿~ 220.132.11.9 06/16 23:16
推 larylary:我是他歌迷也傻眼 = =大概會被罵死吧 219.68.18.174 06/16 23:17
推 jeamgogo:她絕對是歷屆爭議最大的得獎者 219.84.179.71 06/16 23:16
→ larylary:該不會有金曲模咒吧 = = 219.68.18.174 06/16 23:17
推 zzing:阿妹下屆加油吧.....可惜 61.223.207.149 06/16 23:17
→ lapinyaya:不是阿妹..Penny也ok啊!!!!!218.167.229.188 06/16 23:17
推 koinic:阿妹這張感動到半死 也沒得獎喔 幹218.171.163.157 06/16 23:17
推 stephaniexu:阿妹、林憶蓮、PENNY 都比較好壓.....125.231.147.232 06/16 23:17
推 adoretaiwan:我只想說一聲：幹！ 220.140.19.33 06/16 23:17
推 light0:評審出來說吧，她贏過其他人什麼？ 61.217.219.238 06/16 23:17
→ liquormania:PENNY明明就比他好太太太.....太多了 220.141.14.247 06/16 23:17
→ dance4what:===========鄉民是幕後推手=========== 140.115.213.17 06/16 23:17
推 Lattewang:阿妹~~t.t 218.211.213.62 06/16 23:17
推 foreignerdua:張惠妹勒.....怒...125.232.140.191 06/16 23:17
推 kkarashi:......................................140.119.150.145 06/16 23:17
推 fatfatman:台灣樂壇被主流市場害死了122.124.104.225 06/16 23:17
推 yvette3975:YA!最愛JOLIN 218.166.113.93 06/16 23:17
推 ztdxqa:阿妹沒得實在是...... 140.115.211.13 06/16 23:17
推 carryon350:為什麼不是阿妹((跑去撞牆)) 59.105.91.121 06/16 23:17
→ jiazha:阿妹這張真的很棒耶 從真實之後最有希望的ꐠ220.137.200.186 06/16 23:18
推 dokota:啊啊 我賭張韶涵的啊...錢全沒了 220.135.78.51 06/16 23:18
推 cutebabylin:恭喜Jolin ^^ 61.62.155.85 06/16 23:18
推 anneann:最受歡迎+最努力 不等於最佳演唱!!!218.168.213.225 06/16 23:18
推 kaorukoganei:我要快樂這麼棒... 〒△〒 61.64.87.222 06/16 23:19
→ pichuanlin:阿妹+1... 219.84.71.190 06/16 23:19
推 lanyiling:不是說蔡不會唱，是其它入圍者唱更好 .. 123.194.81.109 06/16 23:18
→ bleach00:評審快出來說清楚 ...... 122.127.4.44 06/16 23:18
推 asoshi:太棒ㄌ 59.117.189.194 06/16 23:19
推 lapinyaya:超想哭的..............218.167.229.188 06/16 23:20
→ jiazha:蔡真的很努力 但是其他入圍有更適合的.....220.137.200.186 06/16 23:20
→ kaorukoganei:補一下 曹格唱我要快樂也是很好聽 61.64.87.222 06/16 23:19
推 sasa44:操作的很明顯啊 她一宣布入圍我就覺得會得 59.116.131.16 06/16 23:19
→ jazzDT:幫推!!! 59.116.19.96 06/16 23:20
→ lapinyaya:我支持阿妹!! Penny,林憶蓮也ok...218.167.229.188 06/16 23:20
推 aspili3031:囧......入圍六人中她唱功最弱吧= = 125.225.9.231 06/16 23:21
推 Vataeli:我哭了 阿妹這張真的很棒很棒 61.228.32.250 06/16 23:22
→ lapinyaya:但不會是蔡依林啊...雖然他其他方面不錯218.167.229.188 06/16 23:21
→ lapinyaya:超想大哭的!!! 阿妹也很努力啊.....218.167.229.188 06/16 23:22
推 morningmist:ㄔㄅㄉ ㄉㄘㄟ 218.166.122.43 06/16 23:23
推 Athos:蔡很OK..但其他入圍者唱得更好啊~PENNY >"< 219.86.34.127 06/16 23:22
推 kenic:好開心喔~~~~ 210.68.39.214 06/16 23:26
推 weichen88:扯 她是六個中唱功最弱的耶!! 220.142.90.45 06/16 23:24
推 nono2004:為什麼是她????????????????? 218.170.40.215 06/16 23:27
推 c7939655:她很努力!實至名歸! 61.62.172.31 06/16 23:43
推 chickengod:努力等於得獎!? 那我也可以當評審了 59.117.248.128 06/16 23:47
推 wwiy:........................ 123.240.44.104 06/16 23:50
推 LACENI:菜一林拿最佳女歌手 台灣不能再亂下去123.192.155.193 06/16 23:54
推 crack:JOLIN也不錯阿 支持他 60.250.230.70 06/17 00:10
推 lobelia:覺得很失望 奇怪的評審 140.112.234.96 06/17 00:13
推 c7939655:蔡得獎!罵到評審~是怎樣!你有資格當嘛? 61.62.172.31 06/17 00:30
推 blue666666:覺得阿妹的等級整整高了腸妹兩級......125.228.230.251 06/17 00:48
推 Angelgo:..........氣得罵髒話 219.68.225.83 06/17 00:49
推 woody720604:讚 218.160.25.214 06/17 00:53
推 agogoqueen:ya 59.115.6.5 06/17 00:55
推 hotsauceccc:感謝不看好我的人 讓我更進步 周?140.120.222.107 06/17 00:58
推 ftsymoon:恭喜JOLIN~~~超棒!!!220.131.231.139 06/17 02:04
推 ferlie:恭禧 JOLIN218.170.139.247 06/17 02:14
推 spig0321:努力=/=實力!阿妹出道10年不努力嗎? 222.156.6.59 06/17 02:38
推 Yooko:噓!只能說蔡腸得痣啊......冏rz 59.117.126.197 06/17 04:38
推 GOYOUR:太棒了 喜歡JOLIN 218.171.60.144 06/17 09:06
推 allwen:阿妹+1220.228.157.102 06/17 12:15
推 cute18:原來傻眼的不是只有我.............. 125.232.232.70 06/17 17:31
推 yaper:以後大家都整型好了 媽媽姐姐妹妹女兒一起來 218.163.123.76 06/18 13:26