※ 引述《markwu123 (統一獅Ace投手：馬克吳)》之銘言：
: : couple points.
: : 1. who is this guy? what level baseball can he play?
: : you think he can point out the flaw of the swing mechanics
: : of a professional player? and then the pro player can't and
: : his coach can't figure it out?
: 只准Albert Chen放火，不准milktea liou 點燈？
: 你舉一個所謂的名球評
: 當然我們也舉一個有公信力的大大的資訊來反應啊
: : 2. this guy took a picture that #53 obviously was fooled by
: : a outside fastball at this at-bat, which caused the bad piece of
: : hitting at this at-bat. so do you think it happens all the time??
: : if you want to analyse the mechanics of a player, you should take his
: : normal mechanics that he does every single time at practice, not taking
: : a bad piece of hitting that was fooled at that at-bat.
: : back to point one, if this guy can't tell what's the key which made this
: : bad piece of hitting, i doubt his baseball knowledge and why should i
: : believe him??
: 簡單來說，黃甘霖那一球和人家就是天差地的揮棒
: 你不要和我說因為他們是大聯盟和cpbl鳥蛋聯盟的揮棒
: 更何況那一球還是黃甘霖擊安打的揮棒，
: 也不要和我說這是他失去打擊重心的失敗揮棒
: 因為黃甘霖他那時的揮棒就是這樣子
ok, i respect your points.
but let me repeat my point, if i want to analyses a player, i definitely
choose a representive subject. that would be more presuasive.
besides, i totally disagree people say at that period that
he swung his bat every single time like the pics showing.
impossible!!
: : 3. to me, i agree that some poeple said injuries made #53 lose
: : his swing mechanics that making him from a franchise player to
: : bench player. but i don't think that's a major issue. like i said
: : in the tier one, i can't convince myself the fact that
: : a pro player and coach can't see a obvious
: : mistake in his swing that a layperson can see.
: : so my point is by looking the pic, #53 seems to struggle to
: : hit baseball outside, and let's remind you, if you ever play
: : little baseball, you can see how often that happens.
: 所以你就知道，為什麼台灣職棒沒幾隻棒子可以面對高階聯盟了
: 台灣職棒是一個低階聯盟
: 教練也沒有經過專業的訓練，多半是退休球員直接上陣
: 對於選手的技術上的指導，在媒體報章上，
: 多以心態的方式去做提升
: 要不要看專業教練和非專業教練的打擊教導
: 你看一下黃龍義在2004年金剛式的在2004年後由大田教導之後的差別就知道
: http://blog.xuite.net/johnason/milktea/236822?st=c&w=34051&re=list&p=1
thanks for your information. i will read it carefully.
: : so i can make a piece of advice to #53, i would say work hard on how to
: : hit baseball outside. practice, practice and practice. and then
: : he probably is more familiar with what's the good timing to
: : hit a bseball outside. to me, that's key, not his swing mechanics.
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 128.59.150.90