這一張觀眾票選4顆半
http://www.rollingstone.com/reviews/cd/review.asp?aid=32374&cf=8351

THE ROLLING STONE REVIEW


Too often forced to conform to angel-whore formula,
African-American sisters rarely have the chance
to get individually freaky on the mike.
But if Erykah and Missy can break the rules of radio R&B,
then Macy Gray -- the latest protoge of Wallflowers
and Fiona Apple producer Andrew Slater --
might be able to do the same for VH1 rock.

With an attention-getting croon somewhere
between Billie Holiday's wounded cry and Bob Dylan's feisty rasp,
this L.A. scenester is the centerpiece of an album that sounds
like a John Dahl film looks -- shadowy,
classic and shimmering with contemporary nostalgia.

When the melodies get singsongy and forgettable on "Still" and elsewhere,
Gray comes across as stilted,
and the retro arrangements,
featuring multi-instrumentalist Jon Brion and other red-hot outsiders,
seem overly styled.

But on substantial songs like "I've Committed Murder,"
in which she confesses to killing her boyfriend's boss
over the theme from Love Story,
Gray glides through the aural cinema like a destined star.
Rock needs more of these. (RS 819)

BARRY WALTERS