United v City 賽後評分

[thisbook (^^)]

SKYSPORT  http://tinyurl.com/l9dzyy

 Manchester United Player ratings 

                         評語                  SKY    球迷
Ben Foster               Suspect                6      3.7
John O'Shea              Steady                 7      5.6
Rio Ferdinand            Shaky                  6      4.4
Nemanja Vidic            Decent                 7      6.4
Patrice Evra             Good going forward     8      7.4 
Darren Fletcher          Excellent              9      8.8 
Ryan Giggs               Superb                 8      8.8 
Park Ji-Sung             Worked hard            7      6.5
Wayne Rooney             Not at his best        7      7.5
Dimitar Berbatov         Should have scored     7      6.5
Anderson                 Sloppy                 6      6.6
Antonio Valencia (Sub)   Made an impact         7      6.3
Michael Carrick (Sub)    No time to impress     5      5.2
Michael Owen (Sub)       Struck the winner      7      8.1




M.E.N    http://tinyurl.com/nned5h

United 4 City 3: Player ratings

Foster: 5
Should have smashed clearance into back row for City's first goal and
beaten on near post for last

O'Shea: 6
Was shocked by Bellamy's goal and had a mixed battle with the
Welshman

Ferdinand: 6
Didn't react to Tevez's ability to chase down balls for City's
first and awful slack lob set up final equaliser

Vidic: 7
With only one striker to handle between two he wasn't able to stamp
himself on game

Evra: 7
The sideshow tangle between him and Wright-Phillips was an enthralling
match up

Park: 6
Didn't hurt City's arguable Achilles heel Bridge enough and shooting
didn't damage Blues either

Fletcher: 8
Patches when he was dominant in midfield and times when out of tune
but his two-goal effort won the day 

Anderson: 7
When De Jong was on top in first half he hardly showed but he got
his foot in the door in second

Giggs: 9
A key man in for the Reds - especially the goals - and energised the
side in second half 

Rooney: 8
Started off like a train with opener but then was absent from action
too often 

Berbatov: 7
Had chances to be derby hero but gave Given every chance to be a
hero

Subs:

Valencia: (sub Park 62) 6
Put in some inviting crosses

Owen: (sub Berbatov 77) 6
Cool winner

Carrick: (sub Anderson 90)
Too late to make impression


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 118.170.205.138
推 Nodick:昨天下半場的Giggs 真的是太神了
推 football:Foster的6分真是嚇死我 3~4分比較符合我對他的評價 ㄎㄎ
→ okwool:Carrick太晚上場  比Foster低分應該很想哭吧...XD
推 GordonBrown:Carrick: 我懷疑被忽略了,記者拿前幾場的數據交差...
推 ksaon:Carrick明明就扮演了很重要的角色XD