SKY 球迷 評語
Edwin Van der Sar 6 6.2 Not at fault
Gary Neville 7 6.1 Steady
Rio Ferdinand 7 6.2 Composed
Nemanja Vidic 8 6.5 Dominant
Patrice Evra 6 6.1 Okay
Cristiano Ronaldo 6 6.6 Not at best
Darren Fletcher 6 5.6 In and out
Paul Scholes 9 8.1 Class
Ryan Giggs 7 6.3 Clever passes
Wayne Rooney 7 6.0 Peripheral but spirited
Louis Saha 7 5.5 Dangerous but injured
Michael Carrick (SUB) 6 5.8 No real impact
Ji-sung Park (SUB) 7 6.6 Busy
http://home.skysports.com/matchratings.aspx?fxid=298590&clid=1&cpid=8
Manchester Evening News 的評分
VAN DER SAR: 8
Some vital saves, one superb from Sibierski with his legs, in
the first half when Newcastle fancied their chances
NEVILLE: 7
Uncompromising tackling upset those sensitive Geordie souls, but
might have done more to stop Milner's goal
FERDINAND: 6
Caught flat-footed by Sibierski's header in first half but
generally in control of the situation
VIDIC: 7
The return of his solid Serbian presence was welcome for a defence
that occasionally rocked against Reading
EVRA: 7
Bright and chirpy on the left, he adds more attacking options than
Heinze does, with no defensive worries
RONALDO: 7
His goal-scoring and level of performance had to flag some time, and
this was it, although he still posed problems
FLETCHER: 5
Did the tough stuff in midfield but his lapse of concentration let
Edgar in for the equaliser
SCHOLES: 8
Is there really something wrong with his eyesight? Both goals were
like threading needles, executed superbly
GIGGS: 7
Not the flashing winger of old, but showed his versatility and eye for
a pass with a hand in both goals
ROONEY: 7
Still a notch or two below his best, but his strong running and
tirelessness caused Newcastle headaches all night
SAHA: 5
Missed one excellent chance and had a header blocked on the line before
limping off injured
Substitutes
PARK: (Saha 36) 5
Clever running but skied a great late chance to win it
CARRICK: (Fletcher 77) 5
Got forward well but not much time to sway things
http://tinyurl.com/t4e32
--
★ ╔╦═╮╔╮ ╭╔╮ ╭╔╦═╮ ╔╮╔╮╭╦═╮╔╮═╮ ☆
☆ ╠╬╦╯╠╣ ║╠╣ ║╠╣ ║ ╠╣╠╣╠╬═╣╠╣ ║ ★
★ ╰╝╰╯╰╝═╯╰╝═╯╚╯═╯ ╰╰╯╯╰╝ ╰╰╝ ╰ ☆ ★
╔╮═╮╭╦╦╮╭╦═╮╭╦╦╮╔╦═╮╔╮ ╔╦═╮╭╦═╭═╦╮╮ ╔╮
╠╣ ║ ╠╣ ╚╩╦╮ ╠╣ ╠╬╣ ╠╣ ╠╬╦╯╠╣ ║ ╠╣╚═╬╣
╰╝ ╰╰╩╩╯╰═╩╝ ╚╝ ╚╩═╯╰╩═╯╰╝╰╯╰╩═╯═╩╯╰═╩╝
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.120.93.94