※ 引述《KevinLan (Posaunenblaeser)》之銘言：
: ※ 引述《superego (改~~嘴形)》之銘言：
: : 我覺得..他們好像隨時都準備好要鼓掌似的...
: : 演奏中不時可以聽見"拍"的聲音.....
: : 還有細索的談話聲...
: : 唉.....
: 聽說有某些學校一口氣就帶了上百的學生來聽...
: 在這種情況下...
: 如果不先事前教育一番...
: 比如說至少該告訴小孩子們交響曲有四個樂章、樂章間不該拍手...
: 那只要那個小孩子一不小心拍起來就是想控制也控制不住了.....
A little experience in America. It's almost impossible that each person
in the audience knows when he/she is supposed to applaud. I think every
orchestra more or less experiences this kind of situation. As long as it
doesn't disturb the performance and doesn't happen during the music (of
course I mean the classical music.) that should be fine.
Some people's (I mean music professional)
philosophy is that the concert hall is not a church. You applaud as long as
you feel the atmosphere is right. Litsening to music is to have fun, not to
take a class or something. Of course it is great to teach kids the basic
structure of a symphony and the basic (traditional?) behavior during a
classical concert. But don't expect you can find an audience behaving
like you expected.
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.twbbs.org)
◆ From: hep.Stanford.EDU