Re: [新聞] Alex Rodriguez out for 10 weeks

[richertkk (黃家大少)]

剛在追這個報導時看到一篇外電
http://tinyurl.com/dy9owj

這篇文章剛好在講這個症狀
裡面有一段話
"In many cases, a hip labral tear causes no signs or symptoms and doesn't
require treatment. Occasionally, however, a hip labral tear may cause pain or
a "catching" sensation in the hip joint."

不過文章也提到這個病症會有幾點影響
1.會讓患者感到疼痛
2.會降低患者能購活動自如的range..

so..我想洋基希望最好的情形..就是A-rod能和去年Chase Utley 一樣打一年然後季後
再動手術.


而彼得胖也提出幾個可能的人選
1.Scott Rolen ($22 million over two years)
2.Bill Hall   ($24.45 over three years)

還有其他他想到的人選:Melvin Mora, Chone Figgins, Mark Teahen, Garrett Atkins,
Chad Tracy. Maybe Hank Blalock. 也可以考慮看看老虎的Brandon Inge.

然後最便宜的選項就是:Mark Grudzielanek 因為他是FA

而以一個球迷來講心情是挺複雜的:

1.A-rod剛面對完一脫拉庫的事情..他一定很想打出怪物般的成績來證明自己..
  so如果他開刀治療(算最少4個月)..他今年的成績就一定不好
  所以以後的人看到一定會說 "我就說他07年也吃藥你就不相信.."之類的屁話

2.不過他還要待在洋基那麼久..如果可以有勉強可以接受的替補人選:ex:Rolen
  那我個人還是希望他能去開刀治療..然後再8~9月戰績最緊張的時候回來..
  讓他能夠在那段幫助球隊..這才是做重要的...



不過個人認為A-rod應該是想開刀..不然就不會有他兄弟先出來放話要開刀治療...
然後洋基應該是希望A-rod先打完這個球季再說..所以才會想用復建的方式來處理






※ 引述《ccpz (OoOoOo)》之銘言：
: Hip expert: A-Rod will need surgery
: http://yankees.lhblogs.com/2009/03/05/hip-expert-a-rod-will-need-surgery/
: 所以說如果小的話,休息也許可以解決,開刀復健也不用太久
: 可是變大的話連跑步都有影響, 就一定要開刀,而且要休息一段時間
: I just spoke to an expert, Dr. Robert Buly of the Hospital for Special
: Surgery in Manhattan. He is an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in hips.
: Only last week, Dr. Buly presented back-to-back papers on treating this very
: injury with Dr. Marc Philippon, the surgeon treating Alex Rodriguez.
: According to Dr. Buly, A-Rod likely has an impingement in his hip socket, a
: common injury for athletes. It comes from the femoral bone hitting the rim of
: the socket. The labrum, he said, is like a rubber gasket around the socket. A
: torn labrum is a symptom of the impingement.
: A cyst such as the one A-Rod is typical in these cases. “That’s an
: indication something has gone bad with the hip,” Dr. Buly said.
: Dr. Buly said it is “not unreasonable” to try rest and rehab. “But at some
: point you have to bite the bullet and have the surgery. It’s going to get
: progressively worse and for the patient, it’s pretty miserable,” he said.
: A-Rod’s ability to play depends on the size of the tear and how quickly it
: gets larger. At some point, surgery will be needed. If it is only soft
: tissue, the recovery time is six to eight weeks. If bone must be repaired, it
: would take three to four months.
: Brian Cashman indicated today that surgery would knock A-Rod out for four
: months, so it is likely he has some sort of bone deformity. This comes from
: wear and tear or some sort of anatomical abnormality.
: Dr. Buly, who is a Yankees fan, said A-Rod would soon have trouble pivoting
: or flexing. Running, at least at first, will not be a problem.
: Only time will tell how the Yankees handle this. But keep this in mind:
: Cashman said all last season that Jorge Posada’s torn labrum could be
: treated with rest and rehab. Then on July 30, as Posada underwent surgery,
: they made a surprise trade for Pudge Rodriguez.
: I would expect the same in this case. What is the point of babying A-Rod
: through the season only to see him break down in September and October? Make
: a trade now, get the surgery and perhaps he returns by the All-Star break.
: Scott Rolen ($22 million over two years) and Bill Hall ($24.45 over three
: years) have a lot of money left on their deals. That would be a lot to spend
: on a half-season patch. But maybe there is a 3B out there to be had. Or
: perhaps Milwaukee would give some money back to be free of Hall’s deal. In
: this economy, trade parameters are changing.
: You want some other names? Off the top of my head how about Melvin Mora,
: Chone Figgins, Mark Teahen, Garrett Atkins, Chad Tracy. Maybe Hank Blalock.
: Detroit could part with Brandon Inge.
: Mark Grudzielanek is a free agent. That would be the cheap out.
: Point is, there are a lot of options out there.

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.46.156.145
推 OoyaoO:不過現在要玩交易就要有被搶的心裡準備了
被搶也要認了...現再去哪生一個幾乎要用一整季的3B...哀...
※ 編輯: richertkk       來自: 114.46.156.145       (03/06 10:38)
推 bymee:錢丟得越多，新秀就可以失去得越少吧...= =!
推 OoyaoO:現在開刀算五個月好了 要明星賽後才可以上場了
→ OoyaoO:不過真的去開刀 我猜會看到Teixeira在3B Swisher在1B
→ Belladonaa:Swisher 這步棋變得更神了
→ Belladonaa:Cashman: Swisher 是一壘手
→ OoyaoO:Cashman：你看 我沒有騙你們吧 他真的是來當一壘手的
恩...其實我也很希望鐵爺能守3b...
不過......
http://tinyurl.com/am4twy
"We want to make the team better," Teixeira told reporters. "You guys don’t
want to see that. I don’t want to see that."


※ 編輯: richertkk       來自: 114.46.156.145       (03/06 10:49)
→ OoyaoO:春訓還有一個月 真有這打算的話 很快就可以看到鐵爺3B了
→ OoyaoO:不過現在去開刀的話"我就說他07年也吃藥你就不相信"這種屁
→ OoyaoO:話一定會跑出來 搞不好還有更酸的
推 dp44:1不太可能吧 他在藍鳥耶
好樂迪都有被交易出去的傳言了...對洋基來說"nothing is impossible"
※ 編輯: richertkk       來自: 114.46.156.145       (03/06 10:51)
→ smalleso:鐵爺守三壘的數據還蠻慘的耶XD
推 PoisonM:Rolen這幾年也滿痛痛的 因傷打打停停...
推 Belladonaa:Joel Sherman 有提到 Blake DeWitt
→ IHSV:還有Justin Leone可以選擇。http://tinyurl.com/8nvl5a
推 ccc73123:大砲來洋基都要去守三壘阿XD
推 kobejo4:A-ROD真的決定動刀說不定隔天新聞:洋基簽下Manny
推 OoyaoO:樓上撥接網路嗎？Manny昨天就結束了
推 JamesBond:可能他還活在聖誕節期間那段自嗨的階段
推 kobejo4:傻了  大LAG
推 neptune317:傷痛程度可能有差  要看ARod自己會不會很痛
→ neptune317:去年Utley幾乎沒喊過痛
→ neptune317:賣肉就完全相反
推 goopa:Utely下半季的成績比上半季退步不少，不能以為他是超人沒喊
→ goopa:痛就以為影響不存在...
→ goopa:Utley去年上半季OPS=0.955 下半季OPS=0.855 整徵差了10個%
→ goopa:事實上他07年的成績是0.976
推 kinghwang443:還是開刀比較好啦，畢竟綁了9年約了，不可不慎啊