→ jayin07:是有點意外A's不是排第二 02/07 07:22
※ 編輯: Belladonaa 來自: 118.160.65.183 (02/14 06:05)
http://www.baseballhq.com/books/
==
Team organization ratings/rankings (Overall Grade):
(weighted with top end talent being the most important, depth the least)
1. Texas (A)
2. Tampa (A-)
3. Oakland (A-)
4. San Francisco (A-)
5. Baltimore (B+)
6. Cleveland (B+)
7. Boston (B)
Individual grades: Hitting (B), Pitching (B-), Top (B), Depth (B+)
8. Atlanta (B)
9. Florida (B)
10. St. Louis (B)
11. Cincinnati (B)
12. Kansas City (B-)
13. Milwaukee (B-)
14. Minnesota (B-)
15. Los Angeles (NL) (C+)
16. New York (AL) (C+)
17. Colorado (C+)
18. Philadelphia (C+)
19. Toronto (C+)
20. Pittsburg (C+)
21. San Diego (C+)
22. Los Angeles (AL) ( C)
23. Chicago (AL) ( C)
24. Seattle (C-)
25. Washington (C-)
26. New York (NL) (C-)
27. Chicago (NL) (C-)
28. Detroit (D+)
29. Houston (D+)
30. Arizona (D+)
==
McKamey's Top 100:
1. Matt Weiters (BAL)
2. David Price (TAM)
3. Rick Porcello DET)
4. Colby Rasmus (STL)
5. Madison Bumgarner (SF)
6. Neftali Feliz (TEX)
7. Jason Heyward (ATL)
8. Andrew McCutchen (PIT)
9. Pedro Alvarez (PIT)
10. Cameron Maybin (FLA)
...
27. Lars Anderson (BOS)
60. Michael Bowden (BOS)
68. Junichi Tazawa (BOS)
74. Josh Reddick (BOS)
96. Daniel Bard (BOS)
97. Yamaico Navarro (BOS)
==
Red Sox Top 15
1. Lars Anderson
2. Michael Bowden
3. Josh Reddick *
4. Junichi Tazawa *
5. Daniel Bard
6. Yamaico Navarro
7. Ryan Westmoreland
8. Michael Almanzar
9. Casey Kelly
10. Nick Hagadone
11. Ryan Kalish
12. Che-Hsuan Lin
13. Luis Exposito
14. Stolmy Pimentel
15. Chris Carter (no age limit for prospects but logical regression)
I believe the order of was meant to read 3.Tazawa 4. Reddick. I say this for
two reasons, Tazawa is ahead of Reddick in the top 100 and Tazawa has a
higher ceiling rating than Reddick. I've never seen McKamey reverse the order
before. My guess, publisher error when Tazawa was signed.
===
Quick and dirty comparison
The following verbal assignments have been made to the designations:
10. Hall Of Famer A: 90% probability of reaching potential
9. Elite Player B: 70% probability of reaching potential
8. Solid Regular C: 50% probability of reaching potential
7. Average Regular D: 30% probability of reaching potential
6. Platoon Player E: 10% probability of reaching potential
Of the 45 listed Sox:
# of 9's: 9
# of 8's: 14
# of 7's: 13
# of 6's: 9
The average team has 4.23 9's. We have 9.
===
9C: Anderson
9D: Navarro, Bard, Tazawa
9E: Almanzar, Hissey, Kelly, Westmoreland, Hagadone
8B: Bowden
8C: Reddick
8D: Kalish, Lin, Middlebrooks, Place, Rizzo, Tejeda, Doubront, Fife, Pimentel,
Price, Weiland
8E: Gibson
7C: Bell, Carter, Chiang, Daeges, Exposito, Johnson, Portice
7D: Bates, Dent, Federowicz, Still, Capellan, Huntzinger
6A: Bailey, Diaz, Jones
6B: Brown, Kottaras, Natale, Van Every, Pauley, Hansack
Conspicuous by his absence, Wagner.
(Omitted by accident ?, he was an 8D last year)
Edit: If Wagner fell to 7E, he might have not made the cutoff. From a quick
scan, I see no batters listed as 7E's and no players less than 6B.
Of the 1012 players ranked, there are (2) 10's Weiters (10C) and Inoa (10E).
===
Junichi Tazawa:
Throws Right, Age 23, 2008 FA (Japan), SP
Rating: 9D (Elite potential with a 30% chance of achieving elite status)
Exp ML Debut: 2009
Potential: #2 Starter
Tools: (five * system where *** = major league average and **** = plus, etc.)
FB: 89-95 ****
SL: 80-84 ***
CB: 75-78 ***
SP: 79-82 ***
Scouting summary:
Short/athletic pitcher with excellent upside due to quick arm, velocity and
two impressive breaking pitches. Repeats 3/4 delivery giving him good command
and mixes pitches in right sequence, keeing hitters off-balance. Unlikely to
spend much time in the minors.
===
Michael Almanzar:
Bats Right, Age 18, 3B, 2007 FA (DR)
Rating: 9E (Elite potential with a 10% chance of achieving elite status)
Exp ML Debut: 2012
Potential: Starting 3B
Tools: (five * system where *** = major league average and **** = plus, etc.)
Power: ****
BAvg: ***
Spd: **** (no sprint time given)
Def: **
Scouting summary:
Tall/athletic infielder with plus bat speed and power potential. Aggressive
approach and lack of plate discipline have limited BA but does make hard
contact when he connects. Arm strength is a plus defensively but lacks
first-step quickness and possesses stiff hands.
===
Michael Almanzar:
Navarro:
2008 9E
2009 9D
Both years:
Power +++
Bavg ++++
Spd ++++ (4.25)
Def +++
Parts of scouting report:
"Uses the whole field and has the bat speed to hit for both power and BA"
"Reduced strikeout rate and better contact percentage were keys to improvement"
"Average defensively with solid arm strength and range at three infield
positions"
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 118.160.68.76