[討論] 情人節檔期三部大片

[sampsonlu919 (笑容後的我其實並不快樂)]

情人節快樂/波西傑克森/狼嚎再起國外的影評都陸續出爐了

首先來看看我最期待的VD
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/valentines_day_2010/

Tomatometer:11%(3/28)
Average Rating:3.6/10

雖然台灣試映口碑還不錯
但美國坦白說有點慘,更糟的是:這也是三部新片當中評價最差的

以下摘錄幾則影評

Sheri Linden (Hollywood Reporter/負)
Like a lot of Valentine's Day gifts, showy and easily forgotten.
就跟情人節禮物一樣,過度包裝而且容易忘記

Victoria Alexander (FilmsInReview.com/負)
Makes you hate the day. Isn't Garry Marshall (76) too old for a fluffy
romantic comedy for teens? Lots of stars get paid for 3 days of easy work.
看完本片會讓你更恨情人節,76歲的蓋瑞馬歇爾或許不再適合為年輕人拍攝
輕鬆的浪漫喜劇了,而且這些演員只要拍攝三天就能拿到片酬了

Phil Villarreal (OK! Magazine/負):2/4
The movie isn't awful, and nor is it an award winner, unless you count
Swift's frontrunner status to add a worst supporting actress Razzie to her
shelf full of Grammys
其實並不糟,但也不可能贏得大獎,除非讓泰勒絲角逐明年金酸莓的最爛女配角獎

揪竟,明年金酸莓會否有泰勒絲呢,我們持續觀察中

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

接著是拉丁性格男飾演的狼人
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/1194949-wolfman/

Tomatometer:32%(11/34)
Average Rating:4.5/10

雖然我不是很期待,不過看樣子沒有想像中差

芝加哥太陽報的Roger Ebert給予正評(2.5/4)
In any event, The Wolfman makes a satisfactory date movie for Valentine's
Day, which is more than can be said for Valentine's Day.
這是情人節最適合的電影,甚至根本是為此節慶量身打造的電影

不過也不難看出Ebert也有暗酸情人節快樂,雖然VD對他而言仍算勉強及格(2/4)

但是也有很多不怎麼喜歡的人
H Magazine的Todd Gilchrist就說:恭喜環球公司拍出凡赫辛續集
(Congratulations Universal - you made Van Helsing 2.)

Bill Goodykoontz (Arizona Republic):2.5/5
The Wolfman ends up a disappointment, then, somewhat interesting in places,
but nothing to howl about
雖然本片有幾處有趣的情節,但由於沒有太多驚喜,因此仍是失望的

Cole Smithey:C-
"An American Werewolf In London" still retains its title as the best werewolf
movie ever made.
"美國狼人在倫敦"依舊是最好看的狼人電影

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

最後來看海神的私生子
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/percy_jackson_and_the_olympians_the_lightning_
thief/

Tomatometer:61%(11/18)
Average Rating:5.7/10

這是三部新片當中評價最好的,也是近期評價比較好的奇幻電影

Bill Goodykoontz (Arizona Republic/正):3.5/5
Percy Jackson isn't a great movie, but it's a good one, trotting out kernels
of Greek mythology like so many Disney Channel references.
這不算是一部偉大的電影,但仍是好電影,因為他用迪士尼頻道的方式點出希臘神話
的核心

Jordan Hoffman (UGO/正):B
Fun, brisk and imaginative
有趣,活潑,而且充滿想像力

當然,也有人不大滿意
Ethan Alter (Hollywood Reporter/負)
What's really lacking in The Lightning Thief is a genuine sense of wonder,
the same thing that brings viewers back to Hogwarts over and over again.
本片缺乏的是真正神奇的奇幻感覺,這就跟霍格華茲帶給觀眾的一樣

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

提供觀眾作為參考,以上

※ 編輯: sampsonlu919    來自: 61.217.192.120       (02/12 01:54)
推 speed2:波西傑克森大勝......
推 cawayigainax:波波大勝
推 winer5482:目前版上的po文剛好相反...>"<
推 windhorses:青蛙 > 情人節 >> 波西 > 娘子漢 >>> 狼人=奪天書
→ windhorses:以上是個人近期看完試片心得...........
推 moilkward:但是我對青蛙完全沒興趣 = =
推 louistop:青蛙真的好看,在國外看完了
推 pptuser:波西 6.2/361票，這分數有點低 接近7才會想去電影院看
推 ACGamigo:情人節被呸得好慘... 而且跟Love Actually好像
推 l5:情人節快樂 是一部情人節觀賞很OK 很安全的電影 不差
→ l5:但是我比較喜歡Love Actually
推 Icestorm:推這篇，中肯有做功課，且不胡言亂語
推 badvalley:這篇是好文 資訊整理的很好 謝謝你的提供
推 aty:情人節快樂跟狼嚎再起都看過了　比較推VD ,wolfman看到快睡著
推 ayakolly:我也推情人節..還蠻好笑的
推 rickykobe:我也推情人節快樂...