→ GOJAM:btw.對你附件五所做摘要有點意見. 218.167.232.214 09/24
→ GOJAM:朱是說費了幾小時協調各部門 218.167.232.214 09/24
→ GOJAM:但在你們搞定之前,俄國救難隊就繞道日本了 218.167.232.214 09/24
※ 編輯: GOJAM 來自: 218.167.232.214 (09/24 07:42)
kicktiger：
附件那篇英文報導是你據以證明中央社報導為假的憑據.
你主要論據在於第二段
以此證實造成俄羅斯救難隊救援延遲的是台灣而非中國
進而推論中央社新聞稿造假
我想板上看得懂英文者比比皆是
大家可以看看這則kicktiger所謂的證據
到底能證明什麼？
答案是： none
報導中的Emergencies Ministry
顯然是俄羅斯的單位
「The Ilyushin-76 plane with 73 rescue workers and
nine crew was delayed by several hours as the
Emergencies Ministry struggled to settle all necessary
formalities. Moscow does not have direct diplomatic
relations with Taipei. 」
這句是說俄國救難人員延遲赴援數小時
是由於俄國Emergencies Ministry要費力解決所有的正式手續 (句號)
莫斯科與台北無直接的外交關係
你憑這句就要把俄國救難隊12小時的delay
從中央社報導的中國 栽贓給台灣
並證明中央社的報導為假
我實在看不出你有何邏輯可言
1.該報導並無指明12小時的拖延,是台灣單方面造成
2.俄台之間無直接外交關係,但俄國救難隊飛來台灣需經多國領空
若不直接從中國通過,勢必繞行. 而這都需要與路經各國接洽
得到各該國的允許,方能飛越各該國領空. (這些事都包括在所謂的'正式手續'裡面)
而這些繞行的成本就是中國沒有開放領空所造成的.
所以中央社算在你中國頭上也沒啥不對.
3.假如按你邏輯,你如何看你附件五？
依照你駁斥中央社、漂白中國、並把12小時延遲推給台灣的邏輯
'附件五'若按你這邏輯,那12小時的延遲推給中國也順理成章
不過你很心虛也很聰明
轉到政治版的文章,就把附件五給省略了
你在兩國版附上的'附件五',我一併附在後面
中國與俄國有正式外交關係,
俄羅斯向你們中國交涉開放領空,一樣耗了數小時還搞不定
逼得俄國只好放棄繞道日本飛來台灣
你中國外交部才在事後一個月發表馬後炮撇清
所以,
這附件五,等於是打了你自己這個[賴給台灣、抹黑中央社、漂白中國]的邏輯一巴掌
*****
附五: 中國外交部港澳台司司長朱祖壽 1999.10.20
朱說明了當天的事情過程. 俄國曾經提出過通過領空要求, 大陸方面幾個小時內
做好了各方面的協調工作, 但是俄方最後選擇從日本路線赴台.
http://www.gwytb.gov.cn/zlzx/zlzx0.asp?zlzx_m_id=1240
附件：
http://www.russiatoday.com/news.php3?id=93933
Russian Rescuers Leave For Quake-Hit Taiwan
MOSCOW, Sep 22, 1999 -- (Reuters) A Russian
rescue team left for Taiwan on Tuesday to help look
for survivors buried under rubble by a powerful
earthquake that hit the island, killing more than 1,650
people.
The Ilyushin-76 plane with 73 rescue workers and
nine crew was delayed by several hours as the
Emergencies Ministry struggled to settle all necessary
formalities. Moscow does not have direct diplomatic
relations with Taipei.
It set off for Taiwan just after 6 p.m. (1400 GMT).
Rescue workers from many countries were due to
help look for thousands of people believed to be
trapped under rubble.
Russia's Emergencies Ministry has been stretched over recent weeks because
it has helped tackle at least five major disasters at home and abroad.
Russian rescue teams helped Turkey cope with an earthquake which killed
more than 25,000 people in August.
The Emergencies Ministry has also carried out rescue work on the sites of
devastating bomb attacks which destroyed several apartment blocks across
Russia and killed up to 300 people over the last fortnight.
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 218.167.232.214