Re: [解題] 高中英文關代

[CKdesire (Free)]

※ 引述《pililinjoy (@￿)》之銘言：
: 我遇到一題題目不知道如何解釋，想請問一下。
: There are many areas ______ nature can be a great teacher.
:          (A)which   (B)that  (C)in which
:          參考書給的解答是C
: 我想原句應該是
:      The nature can be a great teacher in many areas.
:      但是改成There 在前面的寫法時，是否要寫成
:      There are many areas which nature can be a great teacher in.
:      (我不確定這樣對不對，而且會覺得這種寫法不是很必要，第一種寫法比較順)
:      然後把介繫詞in提到前面變成答案 in which
:      請問這樣對嗎???
:      謝謝大家

   應該是
         There are many areas.
       + Nature can be a great teacher in many areas.

     many areas 用 which 代替

 =         There are many areas.
         + Nature can be a great teacher in which.

   介系詞 in 和 which 一起移到句首

 =         There are many areas.
         + in which Nature can be a great teacher.

   整句移到先行詞後

 =        There are many areas in which Nature can be a great teacher.

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) 
◆ From: 61.30.100.74
推 coes:每次在解釋這種題目，學生很常一臉茫然。唉/__\
推 super15:這種狀況我都是要學生把關係子句框起來....
→ super15:然後句子還原..還原過程會發現少了介係詞..句子很不順暢
→ super15:所以當然要加回介係詞...然後再說介係詞可放動詞後面或移ꠠ
→ super15:到關代前面...放到關代前時in which=where..
→ super15:這樣講學生多半能接受...
推 coes:嗯，下次講到這種我會試試，我真怕那種部分學生茫然的眼神
推 pililinjoy:謝謝你，我知道了!