Please respond to the following points:
(Place an X on the line in front of your response.)
1. Quality of technical content
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
1a. novelty
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
1b. value
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
1c. rigor
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
1d. sufficiency of examples
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
1e. cogency
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
2. Clarity of presentation
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
2a. clarity of abstract
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
2b. abstract & paper consistency
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
2c. introduction of subject
V Excellent ___ Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
3. Presentation
V Excellent ___ Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
3a. organization & length
V Excellent ___ Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
3b. expression of English
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
3c. quality of diagrams/captions
___ Excellent ___ Good V Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
3d. appropriate key words
___ Excellent V Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
3e. editorial consistency (xrefs)
___ Excellent ___ Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
3f. bibliography format
___ Excellent ___ Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
4. References to previous works
___ Excellent ___ Good ___ Fair ___ Poor
Remarks:
5. Is a significant problem area addressed?
Remarks:
6. Interest to DSP readers (check one - see
http://www.elsevier.com/locate/dsp):
___ of great interest to most readers
___ of great interest to a few readers
___ of interest to most readers
___ of little interest to any reader
7. Does the paper contribute (check all that apply):
___ new principles
___ new results
___ valuable review or tutorial treatment
___ other valuable contribution to the subject
___ improved understanding
8. Recommendations (check one):
___ the manuscript should be published in Digital Signal Processing (likely
to bring credit to DSP)
___ the manuscript should be published after minor revisions indicated below
___ the manuscript requires major revisions before publication
___ the manuscript should be submitted to another journal, such as
______________________________
___ the manuscript should not be published (likely to downgrade the status of
DSP)
Please note that your recommendation and reviewer report are expected to
cover the Highlights and Graphical Abstract if submitted with the manuscript.
9. Confidential recommendations for the Editors (please use additional page
if needed):
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 1.164.95.29
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/AfterPhD/M.1489339814.A.EE2.html