看板 Cognitive 關於我們 聯絡資訊
【2017 心智哲學研究所春季系列演講】 意識與認知:哲學與科學的跨領域觀點 【主講人】Sascha Fink (德國馬德堡大學哲學-神經科學-認知學程 助理教授) 【講題】經驗的私密性 時間:2017年2月21日星期二,下午2:00~4:00 地點:陽明大學第二教學大樓4樓243教室(電梯請按5樓) 報名網址:https://goo.gl/forms/WNrcV0l9E8Mue5gJ2 簡介: 傳統上,我們認為自己的感官經驗是無法共享的,自己的感覺和經驗,只有自己能感受, 其他人無法觸及,這是意識的「私密性」。由於此特性,以科學(客觀的)方法研究(主 觀、私密的)意識,面臨各種困境。Sascha Fink(德國馬德堡大學哲學-神經科學-認知學 程)以哲學的觀點,探討意識的私密性,如何為意識的科學解套。 Abstract According to a traditional view, some parts of our mental life are hidden from others, the phenomenal aspects being probably the best candidate: I can know first-hand what my dream was like, but I can keep others from knowing about my dreams. All that anybody else but me can claim about my dreams is second-hand, relying on testimony, or is inferred by some fallible theory or supported by some more or less reliable evidence. Several prominent neuroscientists (Edelman & Tononi 2000, Frith 2007, Kosslyn & Ochsner 1994, Palmers 2003, Seth 2010) believe that the privacy of phenomenal experiences raises methodological issues for researching consciousness and limits its scope: Either a science of consciousness cannot be strongly objective, or is limited only to the structural aspects of experiences, or fails to uphold scientific anarchism. In this talk, I analyze which notion of privacy would be necessary to raise such a strong problem. However, I am skeptical that we have reason to believe that phenomenality is private in such a strong sense. Conceptual and empirical arguments show that phenomenality is not public. But not everything that is not public is directly private. So I illustrate a possibility how phenomenality in the actual world can be neither public nor private. In such a "Conscious Clubs", different subjects may share first-hand access to the same phenomenal token. If accepted, any argument for limiting the scope of consciousness studies based on some alleged privacy fails. *本場演講將以英語進行 雖然是哲學所,不過本學期將舉辦一系列「意識與認知」的演講, 找來各領域的專家學者,共同探討意識如何被研究。 此為該系列演講的第一場。以科學研究如何能突破主觀經驗的私密性為主題。 為後續的演講鋪路。 歡迎對意識研究、以及跨領域的哲學探討感興趣的朋友們一起來共襄盛舉。 可以追蹤臉書上面的活動頁面:https://www.facebook.com/events/2041420406084236/ 以及我們的粉絲頁:https://www.facebook.com/ymphilosophy/ 後續的演講活動也正公開中! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 114.45.195.60 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Cognitive/M.1486714228.A.2E6.html