看板 Eng-Class 關於我們 聯絡資訊
我在文法書看到下列說明,但看不懂 We use "I wish ... would ..." to say that we want something to happen. But we do not use "I wish...would..." to say how we would like things "to be". Compare: # I "wish" Sarah "would" come. (= I want her to come) but I "wish" Sarah "was" (or "were") here now. (not I wish Sarah would be) 我的問題 1:我看不懂為什麼不能用 I wish Sarah would be here now. # I "wish" somebody "would buy" me a car. but I "wish" I "had" a car. (not I wish I would have) 我的問題2 : 我看不懂為什麼不能用 I wish I would have a car. 我的問題3:作者下面那句話的意思是? But we do not use "I wish...would..." to say how we would like things "to be". 我的問題1及問題2的答案,作者已經很清楚說明了 = 問題3那句話,但我看不懂 有人知道我的問題3那句話是什麼意思嗎? 我的問題4:下面的how是要翻譯成"多麼"?還是翻譯成"如何"? But we do not use "I wish...would..." to say how we would like things "to be". 我的問題5:下面"to be" 的meaning為何? 是exist 或 happen? 或指什麼意思? But we do not use "I wish...would..." to say how we would like things "to be". 謝謝 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 106.105.195.214 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1442715887.A.FB0.html ※ 編輯: maxmnbqq (106.105.195.214), 09/20/2015 10:25:56
hanslai1123: i wish i had a car. 表示他目前沒有車子。 09/20 12:36
hanslai1123: 一個是將來發生,一個是現在狀況 09/20 12:37
maxmnbqq: 我的問題是為什麼不能用"將來發生"? 09/20 13:07
※ 編輯: maxmnbqq (106.105.195.214), 09/20/2015 13:09:53
apoka: 聽起來很怪啊,wish比較像許願期盼,would又變就想要這樣 09/20 13:46
apoka: 把would改成could就很順了 09/20 13:48
maxmnbqq: 但是作者說 I "wish" Sarah "would" come. 是正確用法 09/20 14:03
hsheng: 其實Sarah would come 或Sarash would be here 都是指 09/20 14:10
hsheng: 講者認為Sarah會來的可能性雖"小",但還是希望此事發生。 09/20 14:12
apoka: 對啊,我講的很混淆,意思是第二句都是現在就要有 09/20 14:12
hsheng: 而Sarah were here. 則表示在這裡的可能性為"零",而做假 09/20 14:13
hsheng: 設語氣的。 09/20 14:14
maxmnbqq: 如果有人能夠回答"問題3",我才能了解作者想表達的意思 09/20 14:19
apoka: 我一開始講錯了,不要理我那句XD 09/20 14:20
maxmnbqq: 不能用的原因作者已經解釋很清楚了=問題 3,但我看不懂 09/20 14:23
※ 編輯: maxmnbqq (106.105.195.214), 09/20/2015 14:27:54
apoka: 想表達「希望當下情況是這樣」時不要用wish...would 09/20 14:28
※ 編輯: maxmnbqq (106.105.195.214), 09/20/2015 14:31:48
apoka: 想表達「希望什麼事情發生」時可以用wish...would 09/20 14:30
maxmnbqq: 問題3的how是要翻譯成"多麼"或"如何"? 09/20 14:34
※ 編輯: maxmnbqq (106.105.195.214), 09/20/2015 14:42:40
hanslai1123: 我覺得,你可以用i wish i would have a car. 如果你 09/20 19:40
hanslai1123: 指的是希望他將來發生的話。 09/20 19:40