作者tucson (tucson)
看板Eng-Class
標題[請益] 為何用限定用法? 為何用非限定用法?
時間Sun Jan 24 20:06:12 2016
以下兩題皆是主詞+及物動詞+ a + 名詞 後接關係帶名詞來修釋該先行詞
但為何一個用限定(沒逗號),一個用非限定(有逗號)?
大家的看法為何?
1. Nowadays many companies adopt a flexible work schedule which allows their employees to decide when to arrive at work-from as early as 6 a.m. to as late as 11 a.m.
2. Tao have developed a philosophy of fishing, which is intended for both bountiful catches and the conservation of marine life
第一句為104年指考第一題
第二句的出處:(高中第四冊第三課)
The reason why the ocean is of such great significance to the Tao people
lies in the geographical environment of Orchid Island. The land being very
rugged and infertile, the Tao people can only plant some crops that are easy
to grow, such as taros and yams, as their staple crops. To maintain an
adequate intake of protein, they must paddle off to sea to catch fish.
Over the years, the Tao have developed a philosophy of fishing, which is
intended for both bountiful catches and the conservation of marine
life. For example, they are used to catching fish with their bare hands,
and they respectfully follow their fishing calendar which corresponds to
the movements of ocean currents. Every year from March to June, the waters
around Orchid Island are frequented by schools of flying fish brought on,
has become the principal fishing season for the Tao.
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 223.139.248.113
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1453637179.A.136.html
→ cerenis: 很多公司都採用一種,非限定;TAO發展出來的,只有TAO這 01/24 23:37
→ cerenis: 樣認為,限定。 01/24 23:37
上面的意思跟原句用法完全相反 原句 公司是用-->限定 Tao 是用-->非限定
※ 編輯: tucson (223.139.248.115), 01/24/2016 23:52:06
→ cerenis: 真的耶我完全誤會限定跟非限定的意思了XD,而且我從高中 01/25 00:56
→ cerenis: 到現在才發現我要笑死。那就要解釋成公司採用的作法是這 01/25 00:57
→ cerenis: 種,哪一種呢?後面補述;TAO的想法就是只有TAO有,我看 01/25 00:57
→ cerenis: 網路上是說可以用同位語解釋。 01/25 00:58
推 mrsianas: Tao的釣魚哲學只有這一個,所以非限定;很多公司都有不 01/25 10:51
→ mrsianas: 同的方式,所以要限定來說明 01/25 10:51