Re: [文法] 想問這兩題

[x77 (肛之戀精術士)]

※ 引述《decfrvgtbhyn (read my name)》之銘言：
: 1.Where was＿＿you picked up the wallet﹖Just near the school gate.
: 　(A)it(B)it that(C)the place(D)the place that
: 為什麼答案是B?  D不行嗎

不好意思這兩題我也不太懂

我覺得原本答案應該是：

Where was the place where you picked up the wallet? just near the
school gate

我這個答案是因為where was the place已經是一個完整的疑問句

而後面的where 則是關係副詞，來連結 you picked up the wallet這個子句
來修飾the place


如果原po寫的答案B就很奇怪...that是關係代名詞，但是代替的是什麼？根本找不到...


: 2. Is it in the factory＿＿you visited last week＿＿＿＿this kind of car is ma
: de﹖
: 　(A)X ;that(B)where;when(C)where;that(D)X;when
: 答案是A
: 這題C為什麼不能用？

這題也很怪

我覺得應該是

Is it in the factory you visited last week where this kind of car is made？


同樣道理，where 也是關係副詞，來連結this kind of car is made這個子句

如果用that，一樣會有關係代名詞，但是不知道代替什麼問題...


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 220.135.102.129
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1479135134.A.D82.html
→ gentianpan: 原答案都正確。你2的改法跳脫 it is.... that 的強調
→ gentianpan: 型，你的 it 不在語意中了。
→ gentianpan: 我會反問是什(it)在工廠裡?
→ gentianpan: 1的改法也是跳脫強調型，只是不像你改的2有語病。
→ shene: the place that you...wallet in,此that是關代
→ shene: where was it (虛主詞)that...此that是當名詞子句
推 shene: visit是及物動詞要名詞當受詞,所以需要的是關代,不是關副
→ shene: 1.考that的用法2. 考關代關副基本差異,詞性代表在句中功能