[歷史] 柯潔(黑) - AlphaGo(白) 第一局棋譜

[zelkova (*〞︶〝*)]

因為ptt關係，沒辦法在這邊的棋譜打出柯潔全名請見諒
另外附上網頁版 http://lgs.tw/q6j97if
若有錯誤再麻煩提醒，謝謝


按 z 可進入打譜模式

[  1]● => R16  [  2]○ => Q4   [  3]● => C17  [  4]○ => C4   [  5]● => O17
[  6]○ => F4   [  7]● => R3   [  8]○ => Q3   [  9]● => R4   [ 10]○ => R6
[ 11]● => R5   [ 12]○ => Q5   [ 13]● => S6   [ 14]○ => R2   [ 15]● => S2
[ 16]○ => S7   [ 17]● => Q2   [ 18]○ => P2   [ 19]● => Q6   [ 20]○ => R7
[ 21]● => R1   [ 22]○ => P6   [ 23]● => D10  [ 24]○ => O9   [ 25]● => Q12
[ 26]○ => C12  [ 27]● => C14  [ 28]○ => E12  [ 29]● => C11  [ 30]○ => D15
[ 31]● => D14  [ 32]○ => D17  [ 33]● => C16  [ 34]○ => D16  [ 35]● => E14
[ 36]○ => D11  [ 37]● => E11  [ 38]○ => D12  [ 39]● => C10  [ 40]○ => C15
[ 41]● => B15  [ 42]○ => B14  [ 43]● => B13  [ 44]○ => B16  [ 45]● => A14
[ 46]○ => B17  [ 47]● => F11  [ 48]○ => C7   [ 49]● => H3   [ 50]○ => E9
[ 51]● => F12  [ 52]○ => G3   [ 53]● => H4   [ 54]○ => E10  [ 55]● => E3
[ 56]○ => G2   [ 57]● => C3   [ 58]○ => D4   [ 59]● => D3   [ 60]○ => E4
[ 61]● => B4   [ 62]○ => B12  [ 63]● => A12  [ 64]○ => B5   [ 65]● => B3
[ 66]○ => F13  [ 67]● => G13  [ 68]○ => L4   [ 69]● => L5   [ 70]○ => K5
[ 71]● => K6   [ 72]○ => J6   [ 73]● => K4   [ 74]○ => J5   [ 75]● => M4
[ 76]○ => L3   [ 77]● => M3   [ 78]○ => L2   [ 79]● => M2   [ 80]○ => J2
[ 81]● => L6   [ 82]○ => J8   [ 83]● => P3   [ 84]○ => Q14  [ 85]● => O12
[ 86]○ => S14  [ 87]● => P16  [ 88]○ => R11  [ 89]● => R13  [ 90]○ => S16
[ 91]● => R14  [ 92]○ => R15  [ 93]● => Q15  [ 94]○ => S15  [ 95]● => R17
[ 96]○ => S13  [ 97]● => L12  [ 98]○ => J17  [ 99]● => G17  [100]○ => L17
[101]● => K16  [102]○ => J16  [103]● => G15  [104]○ => H18  [105]● => G18
[106]○ => K14  [107]● => K15  [108]○ => J15  [109]● => M16  [110]○ => H13
[111]● => E13  [112]○ => M17  [113]● => M15  [114]○ => H14  [115]● => R12
[116]○ => S12  [117]● => Q11  [118]○ => R10  [119]● => G9   [120]○ => F16
[121]● => G16  [122]○ => M14  [123]● => N14  [124]○ => M13  [125]● => G7
[126]○ => G6   [127]● => F6   [128]○ => G5   [129]● => D8   [130]○ => N5
[131]● => P5   [132]○ => Q7   [133]● => P4   [134]○ => N13  [135]● => O14
[136]○ => M5   [137]● => O6   [138]○ => M7   [139]● => Q6   [140]○ => D9
[141]● => C9   [142]○ => C8   [143]● => E8   [144]○ => B9   [145]● => B11
[146]○ => M11  [147]● => J11  [148]○ => D1   [149]● => D2   [150]○ => H11
[151]● => J9   [152]○ => K9   [153]● => J10  [154]○ => N16  [155]● => N17
[156]○ => L15  [157]● => N15  [158]○ => L16  [159]● => P7   [160]○ => M1
[161]● => N1   [162]○ => L1   [163]● => O2   [164]○ => O13  [165]● => P13
[166]○ => E1   [167]● => C1   [168]○ => F2   [169]● => E2   [170]○ => F1
[171]● => B1   [172]○ => H8   [173]● => Q8   [174]○ => R8   [175]● => S17
[176]○ => S5   [177]● => S4   [178]○ => T6   [179]● => H7   [180]○ => J7
[181]● => L9   [182]○ => L10  [183]● => M9   [184]○ => K8   [185]● => N10
[186]○ => N11  [187]● => O10  [188]○ => Q9   [189]● => F7   [190]○ => C6
[191]● => P8   [192]○ => P9   [193]● => O11  [194]○ => J12  [195]● => K11
[196]○ => N18  [197]● => O18  [198]○ => M18  [199]● => F15  [200]○ => C18
[201]● => N4   [202]○ => N7   [203]● => E18  [204]○ => O19  [205]● => P19
[206]○ => N19  [207]● => R18  [208]○ => B10  [209]● => A11  [210]○ => A10
[211]● => A13  [212]○ => G8   [213]● => F9   [214]○ => B8   [215]● => L13
[216]○ => L14  [217]● => J18  [218]○ => K18  [219]● => G19  [220]○ => H19
[221]● => E16  [222]○ => E17  [223]● => F17  [224]○ => G14  [225]● => F14
[226]○ => G10  [227]● => H9   [228]○ => H12  [229]● => F10  [230]○ => O5
[231]● => F3   [232]○ => H2   [233]● => L8   [234]○ => L7   [235]● => N6
[236]○ => M6   [237]● => O8   [238]○ => D18  [239]● => D19  [240]○ => C19
[241]● => E19  [242]○ => O4   [243]● => O3   [244]○ => P10  [245]● => P11
[246]○ => E6   [247]● => E7   [248]○ => E5   [249]● => D7   [250]○ => D6
[251]● => T4   [252]○ => T5   [253]● => H6   [254]○ => H5   [255]● => H17
[256]○ => J19  [257]● => A5   [258]○ => A6   [259]● => A4   [260]○ => T17
[261]● => T18  [262]○ => T16  [263]● => K13  [264]○ => A16  [265]● => G12
[266]○ => A15  [267]● => E15  [268]○ => N8   [269]● => N9   [270]○ => Q10
[271]● => B14  [272]○ => O7   [273]● => P6   [274]○ => H15  [275]● => J13
[276]○ => L11  [277]● => K12  [278]○ => F8   [279]● => K10  [280]○ => F5
[281]● => H10  [282]○ => G11  [283]● => M8   [284]○ => K7   [285]● => M12
[286]○ => N12  [287]● => M10  [288]○ => J14  [289]● => H16

《以下為 sgf 格式棋譜》
<golog>
(;GM[1]GN[KeJ-AlphaGo(W) Ptt]
SZ[19]HA[0]PB[KeJ]PW[AlphaGo]
PC[FPG BBS/Ptt BBS: ptt.cc]
;B[qd];W[pp];B[cc];W[cp];B[nc];W[fp];B[qq];W[pq];B[qp];W[qn]
;B[qo];W[po];B[rn];W[qr];B[rr];W[rm];B[pr];W[or];B[pn];W[qm]
;B[qs];W[on];B[dj];W[nk];B[ph];W[ch];B[cf];W[eh];B[ci];W[de]
;B[df];W[dc];B[cd];W[dd];B[ef];W[di];B[ei];W[dh];B[cj];W[ce]
;B[be];W[bf];B[bg];W[bd];B[af];W[bc];B[fi];W[cm];B[hq];W[ek]
;B[fh];W[gq];B[hp];W[ej];B[eq];W[gr];B[cq];W[dp];B[dq];W[ep]
;B[bp];W[bh];B[ah];W[bo];B[bq];W[fg];B[gg];W[kp];B[ko];W[jo]
;B[jn];W[in];B[jp];W[io];B[lp];W[kq];B[lq];W[kr];B[lr];W[ir]
;B[kn];W[il];B[oq];W[pf];B[nh];W[rf];B[od];W[qi];B[qg];W[rd]
;B[qf];W[qe];B[pe];W[re];B[qc];W[rg];B[kh];W[ic];B[gc];W[kc]
;B[jd];W[id];B[ge];W[hb];B[gb];W[jf];B[je];W[ie];B[ld];W[hg]
;B[eg];W[lc];B[le];W[hf];B[qh];W[rh];B[pi];W[qj];B[gk];W[fd]
;B[gd];W[lf];B[mf];W[lg];B[gm];W[gn];B[fn];W[go];B[dl];W[mo]
;B[oo];W[pm];B[op];W[mg];B[nf];W[lo];B[nn];W[lm];B[pn];W[dk]
;B[ck];W[cl];B[el];W[bk];B[bi];W[li];B[ii];W[ds];B[dr];W[hi]
;B[ik];W[jk];B[ij];W[md];B[mc];W[ke];B[me];W[kd];B[om];W[ls]
;B[ms];W[ks];B[nr];W[ng];B[og];W[es];B[cs];W[fr];B[er];W[fs]
;B[bs];W[hl];B[pl];W[ql];B[rc];W[ro];B[rp];W[sn];B[hm];W[im]
;B[kk];W[kj];B[lk];W[jl];B[mj];W[mi];B[nj];W[pk];B[fm];W[cn]
;B[ol];W[ok];B[ni];W[ih];B[ji];W[mb];B[nb];W[lb];B[fe];W[cb]
;B[mp];W[mm];B[eb];W[na];B[oa];W[ma];B[qb];W[bj];B[ai];W[aj]
;B[ag];W[gl];B[fk];W[bl];B[kg];W[kf];B[ib];W[jb];B[ga];W[ha]
;B[ed];W[ec];B[fc];W[gf];B[ff];W[gj];B[hk];W[hh];B[fj];W[no]
;B[fq];W[hr];B[kl];W[km];B[mn];W[ln];B[nl];W[db];B[da];W[ca]
;B[ea];W[np];B[nq];W[oj];B[oi];W[en];B[em];W[eo];B[dm];W[dn]
;B[sp];W[so];B[hn];W[ho];B[hc];W[ia];B[ao];W[an];B[ap];W[sc]
;B[sb];W[sd];B[jg];W[ad];B[gh];W[ae];B[ee];W[ml];B[mk];W[pj]
;B[bf];W[nm];B[on];W[he];B[ig];W[ki];B[jh];W[fl];B[jj];W[fo]
;B[hj];W[gi];B[ll];W[jm];B[lh];W[mh];B[lj];W[if];B[hd];)
<golog>


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 218.161.45.91
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/GO/M.1495530226.A.74B.html
推 ulycess: 頭推
推 nalaculan: 頸推
推 GuitarLuth: 肩推
推 YSimpson:   腿推
推 none049: 肋推
推 bidodu: 屌推
推 dudu5566: alphaGO中盤後面退讓太多了 柯潔下的是真的好
→ hdjj: 只能說柯潔沒有下的特別不好,只是AG太強了
→ hdjj: 全局都下的很好,結果輸了,聽起來不覺得很諷刺嗎
推 lwei781: 安樂死
推 FacebookGO: 下的很好輸了 表示阿法夠下得更好 得證人類徹底輸了
推 notmuchmoney: AlphaGO什麼時候開始有優勢 點33?
推 OrzJ: 看了一下討論  97手作用比較小
→ OrzJ: 前面96手基本上大勢已定
推 a1013707: 推
推 ja000123: AG積分要坐穩世界第一了
推 ggoutoutder: 機器不會去跟人類排名的 早就撤掉了
推 wz02022:  其實柯潔幾乎是人類最強了 AG卻遠在柯之上
推 NCKU: 之前不是有人算出柯贏進化版AG機率是億分之3
→ wz02022:  前50手左上角就略顯淒涼 連100手都還沒撐到QQ
推 ggoutoutder: 左上角還好吧 重點是上方
推 yys310: 推
推 wz02022:  手割下去我不太喜歡黑形阿0..0
推 micotosai: 啊就對柯下指導棋呀，老師通常對弟子下手不會太狠。不
→ micotosai: 然等等又要去住院了
噓 ggoutoutder: 純噓一日棋迷
→ ggoutoutder: 還在那邊指導棋 住院梗 ZZ
→ jackliao1990: 一日棋迷還會被媒體帶風向呢 如同熱情那篇
→ jackliao1990: 整篇很謙虛 結果棋迷就只看記者畫重點部分
推 micotosai: 回的好快XD 果然氣到彈出來
推 hsiehhsing: 請問F3為什麼要那麼早下
推 ggoutoutder: 台媒真的很會帶風向 那標題真的有夠誇張
→ jackliao1990: 鄉民對於黑DPP的新聞會仔細看前後文 但黑柯潔不會
→ jackliao1990: 那篇也是 前後文都謙虛 但鄉民只看記者畫紅字那段
→ jackliao1990: 更有一堆一日棋迷以為他是輸了之後才說的XDDDDDD
推 LIKAA: 百度圍棋論壇有人提供資料 這次對戰只是單機版
→ LIKAA: 去年alphago我記得光是電費就很高
推 ggoutoutder: 運算法提升了的樣子
推 vencil: 演算法跟硬體設計都有所突破
推 ilw4e: 就演算法(棋感)比以前強，猜得準不用太多無謂計算
推 CGary: 上方損太大 想靠斬龍又被斷 很穩定的一路落後到尾 :(
推 Maybetrue: