Re: [問卦] 數學是不是專屬於「天才」的學科？

[sufferlove (天然呆)]

※ 引述《Xration (胤盛家ノ家庭事情)》之銘言：
: 剛剛無聊查了一下維基
: 什麼高斯 牛頓 龐加萊
: 感覺這些人也太天才了
: 基本上普通人一輩子也追不到他們10幾歲的程度
: 感覺不管什麼學科，認真讀還是能得到回報
: 但是數學不同，努力的人在努力也比不上天才
: 從一開始邏輯思維能力就已經不是同一個起點了
: 數學是不是專屬於天才的學科啊？

感覺也許可以參考音樂天才，節錄莫札特的三段話：

https://www.themarginalian.org/2015/02/24/mozart-on-creativity/

第一段大意是說莫札特不知道靈感怎麼來的，他說``I have nothing to do with
it''，我覺得應該解讀成靈感自己來，莫札特不是故意的：

When I feel well and in a good humor, or when I am taking a drive or
walking after a good meal, or in the night when I cannot sleep, thoughts
crowd into my mind as easily as you could wish. Whence and how do they come?
I do not know and I have nothing to do with it. Those which please me, I
keep in my head and hum them; at least others have told me that I do so.
Once I have my theme, another melody comes, linking itself to the first one,
in accordance with the needs of the composition as a whole: the counterpoint,
the part of each instrument, and all these melodic fragments at last produce
the entire work.

第二段大意是說莫札特不是一部份一部份刻出作品，而是直接整體地知道這個作品：

Then my soul is on fire with inspiration, if however nothing occurs to
distract my attention. The work grows; I keep expanding it, conceiving it
more and more clearly until I have the entire composition finished in my
head though it may be long… It does not come to me successively, with its
various parts worked out in detail, as they will be later on, but it is in
its entirety that my imagination lets me hear it.

第三段大意是說莫札特沒有故意要有原創性／跟別人不一樣：

Now, how does it happen, that, while I am at work, my compositions assume
the form or the style which characterize Mozart and are not like anybody
else’s? Just as it happens that my nose is big and hooked, Mozart’s nose
and not another man’s. I do not aim at originality and I should be much at
a loss to describe my style. It is quite natural that people who really have
something particular about them should be different from each other on the
outside as well as on the inside.

好啦，我是音痴，數學也很爛，我不懂，我聽念數學的人說，讀丘成桐的東西，覺得
簡直是天才，但丘成桐卻說讀陶哲軒的東西，覺得好天才？嗯，至少我聽來的版本是
這樣啦，我一個笨蛋，不可能懂這東西的。

南無阿彌陀佛。

--
南無薩怛他蘇伽多耶阿羅訶帝三藐三菩陀寫。薩怛他佛陀俱胝瑟尼釤。南無薩婆勃陀
勃地薩跢鞞弊。南無薩多南三藐三菩陀俱知南。娑舍囉婆迦僧伽喃。南無盧雞阿羅漢
跢喃。南無蘇盧多波那喃。南無娑羯唎陀伽彌喃。南無盧雞三藐伽跢喃。三藐伽波囉
底波多那喃。南無提婆離瑟赧。南無悉陀耶毗地耶陀囉離瑟赧。舍波奴揭囉訶娑訶娑
囉摩他喃。南無跋囉訶摩泥。南無因陀囉耶。

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 114.24.206.161 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1745004947.A.0FE.html
推 a94037501: 他是真的天才35歲就掛了很多音樂家35
→ a94037501: 歲還寫不出什麼鳥
推 chrisabcd: 天分是真的存在 我姊的小孩不論男女
→ chrisabcd:  幼稚園畫畫都比我厲害
→ chrisabcd: 我姊資管畫畫也不輸美術系的
推 mutsutakato: 後來有人因為太喜歡莫札特寫了一首
→ mutsutakato: 搖滾樂曲rock me Amadeus變成冠軍曲
→ mutsutakato: ，告示板百強第一名
推 todao:  (^ ▽^ )
推 windydancer: 6樓那首記得還入選過美國rap 的排行
→ windydancer: 榜，好聽