作者Coetzee (._.)
看板NBA
標題Re: [情報] 外媒對2017梯分級排名
時間Wed Mar 4 18:27:46 2020
Tier 1: Multi-time All-Star Upside
1
JAYSON TATUM
SF, Duke
Duke
3rd overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 5
2
DONOVAN MITCHELL
SG, Louisville
Louisville
13th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 13
3
DE'AARON FOX
PG, Kentucky
Kentucky
5th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 8
Tier 2A: Starter-level players with All-Star upside
4
LAURI MARKKANEN
C, Arizona
Arizona
7th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 10
5
BAM ADEBAYO
C, Kentucky
Kentucky
14th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 26
Tier 2B: Starter-level players
6
JOHN COLLINS
PF, Wake Forest
Wake Forest
19th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 34
7
MARKELLE FULTZ
PG, Washington
Washington
1st overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 1
8
DERRICK WHITE
PG, Colorado
Colorado
29th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 17
9
DENNIS SMITH JR.
PG, NC State
NC State
9th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 3
10
JONATHAN ISAAC
PF, Florida State
Florida State
6th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 7
11
LONZO BALL
PG, UCLA
UCLA
2nd overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 4
12
O.G. ANUNOBY
SF, Indiana
Indiana
23rd overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 12
13
JARRETT ALLEN
C, Texas
Texas
22nd overall pick; 2017 Fnal Big Board Ranking: 18
Tier 3: Probable long-term rotation players
14
LUKE KENNARD
SG, Duke
Duke
12th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 20
15
KYLE KUZMA
PF, Utah
Utah
27th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 61st
16
JOSH JACKSON
SF, Kansas
Kansas
4th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 2
17
ZACH COLLINS
C, Gonzaga
Gonzaga
10th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 11
18
THOMAS BRYANT
C, Indiana
Indiana
42nd overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 65
19
JORDAN BELL
C, Oregon
Oregon
38th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 27
Tier 4: Underwhelming production, but latent upside
20
FRANK NTILIKINA
PG, Strasbourg
Strasbourg
8th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 9
21
MALIK MONK
SG, Kentucky
Kentucky
11th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 6
22
HARRY GILES
C, Duke
Duke
20th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Rankings: 21
23
TERRANCE FERGUSON
SG, Adelaide 36ers
Adelaide 36ers
21st overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Rankings: 29
Tier 4: Bench guys with clear roles
24
DILLON BROOKS
SF, Oregon
Oregon
45th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 44
25
MONTE MORRIS
PG, Iowa State
Iowa State
51st overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 56
26
JOSH HART
SG, Villanova
Villanova
30th overall pick; Final 2017 Big Board Ranking: 33
27
STERLING BROWN
SG, SMU
SMU
46th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 39
28
JUSTIN JACKSON
SF, UNC
UNC
15th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 15
29
SINDARIUS THORNWELL
SF, South Carolina
South Carolina
48th overall pick; 2017 Final Big Board Ranking: 25
後面還有
Tier 5: Bench guys
Tier 6: Career G-League, European, and fringe players
就不貼了
原文網址：
https://fansided.com/2019/04/19/re-ranking-2017-nba-draft-class/
作者：Trevor Magnotti
這篇時間點是在去年季賽打完評分的，不過我覺得只看去年以前的話
Mitchell應該是比Tatum好一點，甚至Fox也比Tatum好就是了..
原文都有每個順位的理由
Jazz fans don’t read this. Celtics fans, hello.
爵粉請跳過，賽迷哈囉
The rationale for having Tatum over Mitchell, despite Mitchell’s
stronger rookie year and absolute scoring torrent in the second
half of the season: Mitchell, for all of his isolation and
pick-and-roll scoring talent, doesn’t have the same avenues to
taking the next step as Tatum does.
儘管Mitchell的菜鳥賽季表現更強，並且賽季後半段絕對得分猛增，但Tatum勝過
Mitchell的理由是：Mitchell在單打和擋拆得分方面都頗具天賦，但沒有像Tatum
那樣擁有進步的的途徑。
Tatum’s path to reaching the next level of performance
offensively — improving decision-making as a primary and
continuing to progress as a volume 3-point shooter — are a little
more achievable than Mitchell being able to improve his court
vision and handle.
要讓Tatum的進攻方式達到了更高的水平，即提高決策水平，並繼續成為高產
三分射手，這比Mitchell能夠改善球場視野和處理能力要容易得多。
Couple that with Tatum having a higher defensive ceiling, and
being a year younger, and Tatum gets the slight edge for me moving
forward. Keyword: slight. This was a really tough call.
再加上Tatum的防守上限更高，而且還年輕一歲，Tatum擁有微小的優勢使我將他
放在Mitchell前面讓我向前邁進了一步。關鍵字：輕微。這真是一個艱難的決定。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 61.219.175.56 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/NBA/M.1583317669.A.46C.html
推 liuuuuuu : DSJ整個慘 03/04 18:29
推 doooooooooog: 芬蘭司機排有點高了吧... 03/04 18:31
推 JaysonTatum : 這篇專業 03/04 18:32
→ doooooooooog: 比阿爹高 ，問號 03/04 18:32
推 Ten6666 : 樓上要看時間點啊 03/04 18:32
→ Ten6666 : 本季當然是Bam>>>>Lauri 03/04 18:33
→ qazwsx879345: bell有點太高了 03/04 18:34
→ ODFans : 這梯的狀元榜眼都不在第一梯隊裡面 真的慘 03/04 18:35
推 madyoungN : 2017選秀大年實至名歸也 03/04 18:37
推 zxz155206 : Bell 也太高了吧..那麼快就沒人要了.. 03/04 18:38
推 kkl522608 : bell太高了啦 03/04 18:39
推 bridgephenN : 推整理 03/04 18:42
→ njunju : 樂透吹捧年 03/04 18:47
推 thisismasonl: 嘿嘿，結果新人王在前一梯 03/04 18:52
推 WinShot : 那位新人王現在不知道要排第幾 03/04 18:54
推 snow5566 : 庫子馬竟然這麼後面 03/04 18:54
推 qaz985621asd: 當初tatum不是被說上限已經差不多還是怎樣嗎？ 03/04 18:59
推 jefflin0824 : collins應該再前面一點 03/04 19:05
推 abcde010710 : 哇靠我狄龍也太低 03/04 19:13
推 tiger984412 : 球哥也太慘 03/04 19:14
推 sxzc : 我丘粉 合理 Tatum的進化太多了 甚至未來都更明亮 03/04 19:20
推 ericf129 : 這梯不錯! 03/04 19:21
推 Rush0406 : 球被Fox超越了... 03/04 19:22
推 Kazmier : 湖人算不算被球爸薛到啊 03/04 19:27
推 lwei781 : Isaac 被低估吧 03/04 19:29
推 lwei781 : Giles 最近也養出來了啊 03/04 19:33
推 Drzowy : Isaac這季傷前超亮眼耶 03/04 19:34
推 roger2623900: 去年季賽打完褲子排第十五？ 不是很有交易價值嗎？ 03/04 19:34
推 lwei781 : Tatum 防守好太多 03/04 19:36
→ lwei781 : Isaac 傷前 根本就是要走 Siakam, 可愛那條路了 03/04 19:37
推 knight0123 : 我拓ZC好低,另外JOSH J也好慘 03/04 19:41
推 aleajactaest: Bam已經是All Star了 03/04 19:49
推 handfox : Jordan Bell比Dillon Brooks高，太神啦 03/04 20:07
推 tony810619 : 芬蘭司機太高，帶不起隊伍 03/04 20:23
推 combokang : 回17樓 Tatum球探報告不是說上限已到喔 大年樂透也 03/04 20:31
→ combokang : 不可能選已經上限的球員啦 當初的是說他技巧成熟可 03/04 20:31
→ combokang : 以適應NBA 當然這個說法是與體能高技巧粗糙的新秀比 03/04 20:31
→ combokang : 較 03/04 20:31
推 ashebird : 球哥這季不錯 03/04 20:43
推 tiggermm : 這年真是滿滿的天賦 03/04 21:08
推 leffyiscome : 3樓自吹自擂 笑死 03/04 21:51
推 rl55586 : Dennis還有第九 比球哥高喔 03/04 21:51
推 fc12170828 : Bam比芬蘭司機高吧 03/04 22:30
推 gn00152097 : DSJ最好有那麼高 03/04 22:38
推 fredchan1992: 那個bigboard排名好廢 03/04 23:51
推 Taetiseoowo : 芬蘭司機這季超級落賽 03/05 00:22
推 ooplus : 8跟9..？ 03/05 00:50
推 Ibeatyou : DSJ印象中已經連穩定先發都保不住了不是？ 03/05 01:39
推 r44621 : 這梯深度很夠 03/05 01:43
推 hannah5269 : 排出來感覺就不算大年吧... 03/05 09:21
→ kaede0711 : Tatum應該是這梯最強的沒有疑問 03/05 09:47
推 md1011 : 身高真的是有優勢 03/11 11:36