[情報] hardware.fr 2015/05/19反修率 完整版

[qxxrbull (qxxrbull)]

網頁好讀版:https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/PC_Shopping/M.1432182227.A.DFC.html

來源:http://www.hardware.fr/articles/934-1/taux-retour-composants-12.html
不知道解釋的有沒有錯... 有錯請指正

(括號為上一季的數據)
====================================主機板====================================
- ASUS 2,43% (contre 2,86%)
- ASRock 2,61% (contre 2,99%)
- MSI 2,82% (contre 2,65%)
- Gigabyte 2,96% (contre 2,51%)

超過5%返修率的單一型號產品
(其中單一型號銷量超過100片 被上藍色的銷售額小於200片)
- 7,94% ASRock FM2A75 Pro4+
- 6,90% ASRock 990FX Extreme3
- 5,87% MSI Z97 GAMING 5
- 5,87% MSI Z97 GAMING 3
- 5,84% ASUS Z87-PLUS C2
- 5,38% ASRock 980DE3/U3S3
- 5,36% MSI Z97 PC MATE
- 5,31% ASUS SABERTOOTH 990FX R2.0
- 5,21% ASUS H87M-E C2

各晶片組主機板的反修率排序
- 3,30% Z87/Z97
- 2,54% H87/H97
- 2,17% B85
- 1,74% H81

- 3,26% 990
- 3,99% 970
- 2,35% A88X/A85X
- 3,19% A78/A75
- 1,79% A58/A55

只計算Z97/Z87的型號主機板的反修率排序
- ASUS 2,74%
- ASRock 3,51%
- Gigabyte 3,59%
- MSI 4,03%

高反修率的型號
(其中單一型號銷量超過100片 被上藍色的銷售量介於100-200片)
- 5,87% MSI Z97 GAMING 5
- 5,87% MSI Z97 GAMING 3
- 5,84% ASUS Z87-PLUS C2
- 5,36% MSI Z97 PC MATE
- 4,96% ASUS MAXIMUS VI FORMULA C2 Z87
- 4,50% MSI Z87-G41 PC MATE
- 4,31% ASUS Z87I-PRO C2
- 3,78% Gigabyte Z97-D3H
- 3,17% MSI Z97-G45 GAMING
- 3,15% ASUS Z87-PRO C2
- 3,02% ASUS Z87-K C2
- 2,99% ASUS MAXIMUS VII HERO Z97
- 2,85% MSI Z87-G45 GAMING
- 2,74% Gigabyte Z97X-GAMING 3
- 2,73% MSI Z87-G43
- 2,50% ASUS Z87-A C2
- 2,02% ASUS Z97-A
- 1,83% ASUS MAXIMUS VII RANGER Z97
- 1,41% ASUS Z97-K
- 0,94% ASUS GRYPHON Z87 C2
- 0,88% ASUS CM Z97I-PLUS
- 0,85% MSI Z97 GAMING 7
- 0,73% Gigabyte GA-Z87X-D3H 

==================================電源供應器==================================
- be quiet! 0,62% (contre 0,84%)
- Zalman 0,74% (contre 1,72%)
- FSP Group 0,82% (contre 0,83%)
- Corsair 1,55% (contre 1,32%)
- Cooler Master 1,65% (contre 1,51%)
- Seasonic 2,10% (contre 2,31%)
- Akasa 2,56% (contre 2,97%)

銷售量100-200台 高反修率的產品
上藍色=原文中斜體的 這段我看不懂斜體代表什麼 請大家幫忙補充
- 10,00% Corsair AX1200i 80PLUS Platinum
- 6,80% Akasa Venom Power 1000 80PLUS Gold
- 4,59% Corsair CX750 80PLUS Bronze
- 3,23% FSP RAIDER S750 750W 80PLUS Silver
- 3,20% Akasa Venom Power 750

500-550W的高返修產品
- 2,79% Akasa Essential Plus 550
- 2,02% Cooler Master G550M 80PLUS Bronze
- 1,85% FSP HEXA 500
- 1,87% Corsair Builder Series VS550
- 1,75% Corsair CS550 80PLUS Gold
- 1,59% Zalman ZM-500GT 80PLUS
- 1,52% be quiet! Alimentation Pure Power L8-530W CM 80PLUS Bronze
- 1,31% Cooler Master B-Series 500W
- 1,25% be quiet! Alimentation System Power 7 500 W 80PLUS Silver (bulk)
- 1,09% Corsair CX500M 80PLUS Bronze
- 1,07% Corsair CX500 80PLUS Bronze
- 1,02% be quiet! Alimentation Pure Power L8 500W 80PLUS Bronze
- 0,90% FSP RAIDER S550 550W 80PLUS Silver
- 0,73% Akasa Venom Power 550
- 0,57% Cooler Master G500 Series 80PLUS Bronze

600-660W的高返修產品
- 3,06% Cooler Master G650M 80PLUS Bronze
- 2,36% Seasonic P-660 Platinum 80PLUS Platinum
- 1,94% be quiet! Alimentation Pure Power L8-630W CM 80PLUS Bronze
- 1,79% Corsair Builder Series VS650
- 1,69% FSP RAIDER S650 650W 80PLUS Silver
- 1,67% Seasonic X-650 (SS-650KM3) 80PLUS Gold
- 1,43% Corsair CS650 80PLUS Gold
- 1,09% Corsair RM650 80PLUS Gold
- 0,86% Corsair CX600M 80PLUS Bronze
- 0,82% be quiet! Alimentation Pure Power L8 600W 80PLUS Bronze
- 0,73% Corsair CX600 80PLUS Bronze
- 0,60% be quiet! Alimentation System Power 7 600 W 80PLUS Silver (bulk)
- 0,28% Cooler Master B-Series 600W

====================================記憶體====================================
- Crucial 0,50% (contre 0,57%)
- Kingston 0,65% (contre 0,36%)
- Corsair 0,81% (contre 1,20%)
- G.Skill 1,30% (contre 0,97%)

超過100台 高返修率產品
- 13,84% G.Skill SO-DIMM F3-1600C11D-8GSL
- 9,81% G.Skill SO-DIMM F3-1333C9D-8GSL
- 7,21% Corsair XMS3 CMX4GX3M1A1333C9
- 5,90% Kingston HyperX Fury HX316C10FBK2/8
- 4,55% G.Skill SO-DIMM F3-1600C9D-8GRSL

DDR3-1600 4GX2系列的高返修產品
- 5,90% Kingston HyperX Fury HX316C10FBK2
- 3,88% Corsair XMS3 CMX8GX3M2A1600C9
- 2,03% Corsair Vengeance LP CML8GX3M2A1600C9
- 2,03% G.Skill RL F3-12800CL9D-8GBRL
- 1,83% G.Skill Aegis F3-1600C11S-8GIS
- 1,75% G.Skill NT F3-1600C11D-8GNT
- 1,23% Crucial Ballistix Sport BLS2C4G3D169DS3CEU
- 0,95% Kingston ValueRAM KVR16N11/8
- 0,94% Corsair Vengeance LP CML8GX3M2A1600C9B
- 0,92% G.Skill NT F3-1600C11S-8GNT
- 0,85% G.Skill NS F3-1600C11D-8GNS
- 0,76% G.Skill Aegis F3-1600C11D-8GIS
- 0,75% G.Skill X F3-12800CL9D-8GBXL
- 0,60% Crucial CT102464BA160B
- 0,53% G.Skill Ares F3-1600C9D-8GAB
- 0,49% Kingston HyperX Beast KHX16C9T3K2/8X
- 0,20% Kingston HyperX Black KHX16C9B1BK2/8
- 0,00% Corsair Dominator CMP4GX3M2A1600C9
- 0,00% Corsair Vengeance CMZ8GX3M1A1600C10
- 0,00% Corsair Vengeance LP CML8GX3M1A1600C10
- 0,00% Corsair Vengeance Pro CMY8GX3M2A1600C9R
- 0,00% Crucial CT2KIT51264BA160BJ
- 0,00% G.Skill XM F3-12800CL7D-8GBXM
- 0,00% Kingston HyperX Black KHX16C9B1BK2/8X
- 0,00% Kingston HyperX Fury HX316C10FK2/8
- 0,00% Kingston HyperX Genesis KHX1600C9D3K2/8GX
- 0,00% Kingston ValueRAM KVR16N11S8K2/8

====================================顯示卡====================================
- Gainward 1,44% (contre 2,67%)
- Zotac 1,57% (contre 3,09%)
- ASUS 2,08% (contre 3,00%)
- Gigabyte 2,37% (contre 2,98%)
- MSI 2,48% (contre 2,25%)
- Sapphire 2,71% (contre 4,04%)

返修率5%以上 銷售額都超過100片 斜體(藍色)小於200片

- 24,75% Gigabyte GV-N78TGHZ-3GD
- 10,45% Sapphire Radeon R9 290 Vapor-X 4G GDDR5 OC
- 10,08% Sapphire Radeon R9 280X Tri-X 3G GDDR5
- 8,45% MSI Radeon R9 290X GAMING 4G
- 7,61% ASUS Radeon R9280X-DC2T-3GD5
- 7,10% MSI Radeon R9 290 GAMING 4G
- 6,80% Sapphire Radeon R9 290 Tri-X 4G GDDR5 OC
- 6,72% MSI GeForce GTX 970 GAMING 4G 4 Go
- 6,72% Sapphire Radeon R7 250 2G DDR3
- 6,61% MSI Radeon R9 270X GAMING 2G
- 6,60% MSI Radeon R9 270X HAWK
- 6,32% Sapphire Radeon R9 290X 4G 21226-00
- 5,53% Gigabyte GV-N78TOC-3GD
- 5,24% ASUS GTX780TI-DC2OC-3GD5

高端顯卡的反修率
- 3,11% Radeon R9 270
- 3,29% Radeon R9 270X
- 4,62% Radeon R9 280
- 5,61% Radeon R9 280X
- 7,59% Radeon R9 290
- 7,09% Radeon R9 290X

- 1,19% GeForce GTX 660
- 1,79% GeForce GTX 760
- 2,91% GeForce GTX 770
- 3,00% GeForce GTX 780
- 6,27% GeForce GTX 780 Ti
- 0,12% GeForce GTX TITAN/BLACK
- 5,78% GeForce GTX 970
- 0,00% GeForce GTX 980

單一晶片型號的高反修率顯卡 100片以上 斜體(藍字)不到200片

R9 270/270X
- 6,61% MSI Radeon R9 270X GAMING 2G
- 6,60% MSI Radeon R9 270X HAWK
- 3,01% MSI Radeon R9 270 GAMING 2G
- 2,65% Sapphire Radeon R9 270X Dual-X 2G GDDR5 OC
- 1,67% Sapphire Radeon R9 270X Dual-X 4G GDDR5 OC
- 1,46% ASUS R9270X-DC2T-4GD5

R9 280/280X
- 10,08% Sapphire Radeon R9 280X Tri-X 3G GDDR5
- 7,61% ASUS R9280X-DC2T-3GD5
- 4,79% Sapphire Radeon R9 280 Dual-X 3G GDDR5 OC
- 3,92% Sapphire Radeon R9 280X Dual-X 3G GDDR5 OC
- 3,68% Sapphire Radeon R9 280X Vapor-X 3G GDDR5 OC
- 2,75% Sapphire Radeon R9 280X Toxic 3G GDDR5

R9 290/290X
- 10,45% Sapphire Radeon R9 290 Vapor-X 4G GDDR5 OC
- 8,45% MSI Radeon R9 290X GAMING 4G
- 7,10% MSI Radeon R9 290 GAMING 4G
- 6,80% Sapphire Radeon R9 290 Tri-X 4G GDDR5 OC
- 6,32% Sapphire Radeon R9 290X 4G 21226-00

GTX 660
- 1,70% Gigabyte GV-N660OC-2GD
- 1,10% MSI N660 GAMING 2GD5/OC
- 0,80% MSI N660 GAMING 2GD5
- 0,63% ZOTAC GeForce GTX 660 Synergy Edition 2GB
- 0,00% ASUS GTX660-DC2O-2GD5
- 0,00% ASUS GTX660-DC2OCPH-2GD5

GTX 760
- 2,60% MSI N760 TF 4GD5/OC
- 2,01% MSI N760 TF 2GD5/OC
- 1,41% Gigabyte GV-N760OC-4GD
- 1,12% MSI N760-2GD5/OC
- 1,09% ASUS GTX760-DC2OC-2GD5
- 0,29% Gigabyte GV-N760OC-2GD

GTX 770
- 2,89% Gainward GeForce GTX 770 Phantom 2 Go OC
- 2,61% MSI N770 TF 2GD5/OC
- 2,47% Gigabyte GV-N770OC-2GD
- 2,34% Gigabyte GTX770OC-4GD
- 2,15% MSI N770-2GD5/OC
- 1,85% ASUS GTX770-DC2OC-2GD5
- 1,82% Gainward GeForce GTX 770 2 Go
- 1,73% Gainward GeForce GTX 770 Phantom 4 Go

GTX 780/780 Ti
- 24,75% Gigabyte GV-N78TGHZ-3GD
- 5,53% Gigabyte GV-N78TOC-3GD PCI-E
- 5,24% ASUS GTX780TI-DC2OC-3GD5
- 4,09% ZOTAC GeForce GTX 780 OC 3GB
- 3,91% Gainward GeForce GTX 780 Phantom 3GB
- 3,13% MSI GTX 780TI GAMING 3G
- 2,94% Gigabyte GV-N780OC-3GD
- 2,88% MSI N780 TF 3GD5/OC
- 1,96% ASUS GTX780-DC2OC-3GD5
- 0,81% ASUS POSEIDON-GTX780-P-3GD5

===================================傳統硬碟===================================
- Seagate 0,68% (contre 0,69%)
- Western 1,09% (contre 0,93%)
- HGST 1,16% (contre 1,01%)
- Toshiba 1,34% (contre 1,29%)

高反修率型號(100-200台)
- 4,58% WD Red WD60EFRX
- 3,40% Toshiba 3 To DT01ACA300
- 2,93% WD Green 4 To WD40EZRX
- 2,78% WD SE 3 To WD3000F9YZ
- 2,14% Hitachi Ultrastar A7K2000 1 To

各容量區間的產品
2 T:

- 2,03% Seagate SSHD ST2000DX001
- 1,55% Toshiba DT01ACA200
- 1,39% WD Green WD20EZRX
- 1,34% WD SE WD2000F9YZ
- 0,92% Seagate NAS HDD ST2000VN000
- 0,92% Seagate Barracuda 7200.14 ST2000DM001
- 0,83% WD Red WD20EFRX
- 0,61% WD RE WD2000FYYZ
- 0,38% WD Black WD2003FZEX
- 0,32% Seagate Surveillance ST2000VX0007
- 0,00% Seagate Enterprise Value ST2000NC001
- 0,00% Seagate Enterprise Capacity ST2000NM0033
- 0,00% WD AV-GP WD20EURX

3 T:

- 3,40% Toshiba DT01ACA300
- 2,78% WD SE WD3000F9YZ
- 1,49% WD Red WD30EFRX
- 1,36% Seagate Barracuda 7200.14 ST3000DM001
- 1,31% Seagate Surveillance ST3000VX000
- 1,30% WD Green WD30EZRX
- 1,18% Seagate NAS HDD ST3000VN000
- 0,00% Seagate Enterprise Value ST3000NC002

4 T:

- 2,93% WD Green WD40EZRX
- 1,45% WD Red WD40EFRX
- 1,18% WD Black WD4003FZEX
- 1,08% Seagate NAS HDD ST4000VN000
- 1,08% Seagate SSHD ST4000DX001/
- 0,80% Seagate Desktop HDD.15 ST4000DM000
- 0,50% HGST Deskstar 7K4000 H3IK40003272SE
- 0,00% HGST Deskstar NAS 0S03665
- 0,00% Seagate Constellation ES ST4000NM0033

===================================固態硬碟===================================

- Intel 0,15% (contre 0,27%)
- Samsung 0,18% (contre 0,24%)
- Corsair 0,27% (contre 0,87%)
- Kingston 0,32% (contre 0,63%)
- Crucial 0,41% (contre 0,57%)
- Sandisk 0,48% (contre 0,29%)

高反修率型號
- 3,03% SanDisk SSD Extreme II 480 Go
- 1,89% Crucial M550 256 Go mSATA
- 1,50% SanDisk SSD Extreme II 240 Go
- 1,48% SanDisk SSD Extreme PRO 240 Go
- 1,41% Corsair Force Series LS 60 Go

各容量區間

120-128 G:

1,23% Samsung 850 Pro
0,75% Crucial M550
0,58% Crucial M500
0,38% Sandisk Ultra Plus
0,34% SanDisk SSD
0,30% Kingston HyperX 3K
0,22% Kingston SSDNow V300
0,16% Samsung 840 EVO
0,12% Crucial MX100
0,00% Corsair Force LS
0,00% Intel SSD 530
0,00% Samsung 840 Pro
0,00% SanDisk Extreme II

240-256 G:

- 1,50% SanDisk SSD Extreme II
- 1,48% SanDisk SSD Extreme PRO
- 0,57% Sandisk Ultra Plus
- 0,56% Samsung 850 Pro
- 0,51% Crucial M550
- 0,45% Kingston SSDNow V300
- 0,39% Crucial MX100
- 0,31% Kingston HyperX 3K
- 0,30% Crucial M500
- 0,18% Samsung 840 EVO
- 0,15% Samsung 840 Pro
- 0,00% Intel SSD 530

480-512 G:

- 3,03% SanDisk SSD Extreme II
- 0,60% Crucial M550
- 0,30% Crucial MX100
- 0,26% Samsung 840 Pro
- 0,14% Samsung 840 EVO
- 0,00% Crucial M500


--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 61.230.157.188
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/PC_Shopping/M.1432182227.A.DFC.html
※ 編輯: qxxrbull (61.230.157.188), 05/21/2015 12:25:09
推 yang05041833: 推詳細
推 a34021501   : 數據會說話
推 wen09730112 : 24.75% 這...
推 aforied     : intel ssd還真猛
→ reaturn     : 小於200片，所以比例會被放大？
推 love740120  : 980返修率0%...
→ reaturn     : 不過970那個維修率會跟高頻電磁音RMA有關嗎？
推 cannotsleep : 還好有捏住沒買妓家的東西
→ Sugiros     : 印象之前有人用這資料做三大家的每月返修線性圖
推 worm6206    : 這可以當作選購指南吧
推 limingchou  : 技嘉也就780ti比較高不是？
推 gn02143363  : 主機板Z系列都被超壞的吧?!
→ SeanLiao99  : 望向藍寶石跟星星
→ reaturn     : 星星的GAMING系列是怎麼回事…
→ hyperionii  : 還好 270拿asus的
→ ekrik       : 原文有一段MSI 970的說明 看不懂
推 LiNcUtT     : 華擎的高階板看來信賴度不錯? 還是根本沒人買阿? XD
推 wild2012    : 數量太少的 統計資料幾乎完全沒有意義...看看就好
推 swallow73   :  Lorsque l'échantillon est plus faible que 200
→ swallow73   : , la désignation est en italique.
→ swallow73   : 斜體是代表樣品小於200件的?
→ swallow73   : 出貨少於兩百件以下，由於樣本不足、可靠度較低，以
→ swallow73   : 斜體來標示
推 david54001  : 死雞反修率竟然最低
→ corlos      : 死雞2T真的很爛，我就怒換3T了，返修率非常有感 -.-
推 ejywar      : 24,75% 技嘉這塊顯卡的返修率會不會太高啦
→ ejywar      : 另外Akasa這家PSU國內有在販售嗎？
推 blackwindy  : 硬碟部分的結果跟之前那個大型data center的不一樣
→ blackwindy  : 我到底該信哪個...這邊看起來toshiba 3T的都很慘
推 cat05joy    : 真糟糕 3T到底要買TOSHIBA還是HGST..T的反修率有點
推 Gwendaline  : 買WD re啊
推 FastGunMan  : Z97/Z87 返修率最高是消費者超頻搞壞?
→ cat05joy    : WD RE超過預算 XD..
推 nurockplayer: Backblaze是2.7萬顆 樣本比這個高很多
推 MrDisgrace  : 3T都很雷啊 選2T或4T WD3T企業版已經一年壞2顆了
推 awxsd456    : 藍寶顯卡好雷
→ unlimted    : 一堆礦卡狂操嗎？
推 qunxiang    : SSD沒有Toshiba的資料嗎？
推 yys310      : 雞排店愛玩rename結果反修率那麼低？？？
→ Nappa       : 當然是這個比較可信呀 這個是眾多人使用眾多產品
推 hsinyeh     : 請問上色的是個什麼因意思？
推 pipi5867    : 只論硬碟應該是backblaze可信  一般送修有些根本不
→ pipi5867    : 是壞掉
推 ddrdod      : 沒有 Plextor SSD 的返修率嗎？
推 fbicba      : 還好我只用華擎的
→ lovinlover  : backblaze和一般消費者的使用習慣差異應該很大
推 gusony      : 請問有出貨量可以參考嗎??