→ erilinda:they say [who is one of the best..] who當主詞 10/10 17:19
→ erilinda:say的受詞是後面整個句子 所以they say也不是接him而是he 10/10 17:19
推 sitifan:The answer is who, not whom. 10/10 17:22
無法理解
一般來說，題目大都為
He is the novelist ___ is one of the best writers of today.
如果是上句，我會寫who
但題目插入了 they say 兩個字
He is the novelist who they say is one of the best writers of today.
--- ----
主詞 主詞 ==> 語法很怪
我舉例其它題目來說
This is the boy whom we met at station yesterday.
----
同上，原本題目應也為whom
He is the novelist whom they say is one of the best writers of today.
-----
至於解答、推文版友都是who，我還是不能理解，help~~~~~~~
※ 編輯: saininniang 來自: 117.56.64.35 (10/11 16:35)
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
※ 轉錄者: saininniang (117.56.64.35), 時間: 10/11/2013 16:35:51
※ 編輯: saininniang 來自: 117.56.64.35 (10/11 16:36)
※ 編輯: saininniang 來自: 117.56.64.35 (10/11 16:36)
→ AnanP :是不是看到who 接著不是they say 而是 is one of 10/11 17:20
→ AnanP :這樣對你來說比較好理解?? 10/11 17:20
→ AnanP :they say 感覺是另一個插入句 10/11 17:21
→ AnanP :省略了一個 that, 而那個 who 是為求清楚表達代表誰 10/11 17:21
→ AnanP :所以以省略為前提 they say that he is.... 10/11 17:21
→ AnanP :that 可以省略 he 用 who代替 提到novelist後面 10/11 17:22
→ AnanP :這只是我的猜測就是了 10/11 17:22
→ AnanP :因為以你的理解 say 後面通常接人 10/11 17:22
→ AnanP :說錯 接事 以that 去帶出來的N子句 10/11 17:23
→ AnanP :要是也是 they say that he is.... 10/11 17:23
→ i14d14 :我問你 你會說 They say he is the best writer 10/11 18:33
→ i14d14 :還是They say him is the best writer? 不言而喻 10/11 18:33
→ i14d14 :至於你給的例子，We met him at station yesterday 10/11 18:35