Re: [問題] 自古傳武兵擊可能無法實戰？

[helldog (媽寶地狗)]

在1544年的塞雷索萊里戰役
 ，法軍元帥呂蒙克跟手下說了這樣一段話：
Gentlemen, it may be there are not many here who have ever been in a Battel before, and therefore let me tell you, that if we take our Pikes by the hinder end, and right at the length of the Pike, we shall be defeated; for the Germans are more dextrous at this kind of fight than we are: but you must take your Pikes by the middle as the Swisse do, and run head-long to force and penetrate into the midst of them, and you shall see how confounded they will be。

這不證明德意志傭兵在point of pike 方面很利害嗎？你要取勝，只能靠push of pike。

-----
Sent from JPTT on my Xiaomi 22041219NY.

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 114.136.232.29 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Warfare/M.1708165129.A.E5B.html
推 whitertiger: 只能靠push of pike取勝(X)
→ whitertiger: 盡可能先用其他方式取得優勢，再用push of pike收尾(
→ whitertiger: O)
推 whitertiger: 如果是古典時代的戰爭，確實有需要用push of pike來
→ whitertiger: 取勝，但是16世紀的戰爭有其他手段來打，不一定要用
→ whitertiger: push of pike，因為這戰術很傷本，這批訓練有素或有
→ whitertiger: 戰鬥經驗的部隊可能是你的家底，打完就沒了，要重新
→ whitertiger: 招募也要看財力，所以大多打仗是根據偵查情報來進行
→ whitertiger: 用多兵種協同作戰和各種戰術運用來取勝，先前版主連
→ whitertiger: 載的亨利拳四郎傳可以看一下XD
→ whitertiger: 法國將軍這段演講是要鼓舞士氣，至於有沒有效不知道
→ whitertiger: 。