[討論] 各評分網2017夏季電影大盤點

[peter220 (PeterLiau)]

(前言)
夏季檔期結束了
各網站的夏季電影評分也差不多了
我注意到爛番茄網站特別做專題圖表
但這些電影的順序排列讓我忍不住邊看邊搖頭

所以我又查了幾個影評網
盤點了這些電影的平均分數

入選條件:
2017年五到八月上映
至少800間北美戲院播映,或在爛番茄網站上獲得80條以上影評評論
RT為爛番茄好評百分比, MT為MetaCritic評分
同分時以IMDB分數高低為主

59th. The Emoji Movie (表情符號電影)
IMDB: 2.0 (worst 1st) RT: 8% (worst 1st) MT: 12 (worst 1st)
平均: 13.3

58th. The Nut Job 2: Nutty by Nature (暫譯: 堅果行動2)
IMDB: 4.6 (worst 5th) RT: 11% (worst 2nd) MT: 36 (worst 9th)
平均: 31.0

57th. Transformers: The Last Knight (變形金剛5:最終騎士)
IMDB: 5.3 (worst 9th) RT: 15% (worst 3rd) MT: 28 (worst 2nd)
平均: 32.0

56th. Wish Upon (奪命潘朵拉)
IMDB: 4.7 (worst 7th) RT: 18% (worst 8th) MT: 32 (worst 5th)
平均: 32.3

55th. Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Long Haul (暫譯: 遜咖冒險王4)
IMDB: 4.1 (worst 2nd) RT: 20% (worst 10th) MT: 39
平均: 33.3

54th. Birth of the Dragon (龍之誕生)
IMDB: 4.4 (worst 4th) RT: 21% MT: 35 (worst 8th)
平均: 33.3

53rd. The House (無中譯威爾法洛喜劇)
IMDB: 5.6 RT: 17% (worst 7th) MT: 30 (worst 3rd)
平均: 34.3

52nd. The Mummy (神鬼傳奇)
IMDB: 5.6 RT: 16% (worst 4th) MT: 34 (worst 6th)
平均: 35.3

51st. The Book of Henry (亨利之書)
IMDB: 5.7 RT: 22% MT: 31 (worst 4th)
平均: 36.7

50th. The Dark Tower (黑塔)
IMDB: 6.0 RT: 16% (worst 4th) MT: 34 (worst 6th)
平均: 36.7

49th. Baywatch (海灘救護隊)
IMDB: 5.6 RT: 19% (worst 9th) MT: 37 (worst 10th)
平均: 37.3

48th. All Eyez on Me (暫譯: 萬眾矚目)
IMDB: 5.8 RT: 16% (worst 4th) MT: 38
平均: 37.3

47th. Snatched (搶救千金)
IMDB: 4.1 (worst 2nd) RT: 35% MT: 45
平均: 40.3

46th. Kidnap (暫譯: 綁架)
IMDB: 6.0 RT: 34% MT: 44
平均: 46.0

45th. Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales (加勒比海盜 神鬼奇航:死
無對證)
IMDB: 7.0 RT: 30% MT: 39
平均: 46.3

44th. King Arthur: Legend of the Sword (亞瑟:王者之劍)
IMDB: 7.0 RT: 28% MT: 41
平均: 46.3

43rd. Rough Night (女狼嗨到趴)
IMDB: 5.2 (worst 8th) RT: 46% MT: 51
平均: 49.7

42nd. Paris Can Wait (無中譯浪漫喜劇)
IMDB: 5.9 RT: 44% MT: 48
平均: 50.3

41st. Leap! (芭蕾奇緣)
IMDB: 6.8 RT: 35% MT: 48
平均: 50.3

40th. The Dinner (無中譯李察吉爾驚悚片)
IMDB: 4.6 (worst 5th) RT: 53% MT: 58
平均: 52.3

39th. The Hitman's Bodyguard (殺手保鑣)
IMDB: 7.0 RT: 40% MT: 47
平均: 52.3

38th. Everything, Everything (暫譯: 一切的一切)
IMDB: 6.3 RT: 44% MT: 52
平均: 53.0

37th. Churchill (暫譯: 邱吉爾)
IMDB: 7.1 RT: 47% MT: 44
平均: 54.0

36th. 47 Meters Down (深海鯊機)
IMDB: 5.8 RT: 54% MT: 52
平均: 54.7

35th. Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets (星際特工瓦雷諾:千星之城)
IMDB: 6.7 RT: 51% MT: 51
平均: 56.3

34th. Despicable 3 (神偷奶爸3)
IMDB: 6.3 RT: 61% MT: 49
平均: 57.7

33rd. The Glass Castle (玻璃城堡)
IMDB: 7.2 RT: 49% MT: 56
平均: 59.0

32nd. Cars 3 (Cars3閃電再起)
IMDB: 7.1 RT: 68% MT: 59
平均: 66.0

31st. My Cousin Rachel (暫譯: 遺孀美人心)
IMDB: 6.1 RT: 76% MT: 63
平均: 66.7

30th. Alien: Covenant (異形:聖約)
IMDB: 6.5 RT: 70% MT: 65
平均: 66.7

29th. Annabelle: Creation (安娜貝爾:造孽)
IMDB: 7.0 RT: 68% MT: 62
平均: 66.7

28th. An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power (不願面對的真相2)
IMDB: 5.5 (worst 10th) RT: 78% MT: 68
平均: 67.0

27th. Landline (無中譯家庭風暴喜劇)
IMDB: 6.4 RT: 73% MT: 66
平均: 67.7

26th. Beatriz at Dinner (暫譯: 晚宴上的比特麗茲)
IMDB: 6.3 RT: 77% MT: 68
平均: 69.3

25th. Atomic Blonde (極凍之城)
IMDB: 7.1 RT: 75% MT: 63
平均: 69.7

24th. The Hero (無中譯死亡將至戲劇)
IMDB: 7.2 RT: 77% MT: 61
平均: 70.0

23rd. The Little Hours (無中譯修女飆髒話黑色喜劇)
IMDB: 6.6 RT: 77% MT: 69
平均: 70.7

22nd. All Saints (無中譯宗教片)
IMDB: 5.9 RT: 93% (best 2nd) MT: 63
平均: 71.7

21st. Captain Underpants: The First Epic Movie (內褲隊長)
IMDB: 6.4 RT: 87% MT: 69
平均: 73.3

20th. Megan Leavey (暫譯: 梅根李維)
IMDB: 7.1 RT: 84% MT: 66
平均: 73.7

19th. The Beguiled (魅惑)
IMDB: 6.9 RT: 79% MT: 77 (best 10th)
平均: 75.0

18th. Brigsby Bear (無中譯成長戲劇)
IMDB: 7.8 (best 9th) RT: 79% MT: 68
平均: 75.0

17th. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 (星際異攻隊2)
IMDB: 7.9 (best 6th) RT: 81% MT: 67
平均: 75.7

16th. Girls Trip (閨蜜假期)
IMDB: 6.9 RT: 89% (best 10th) MT: 71
平均: 76.3

15th. Ingrid Goes West (暫譯: 網美嬉遊記)
IMDB: 7.3 RT: 87% MT: 71
平均: 77.0

14th. It Comes at Night (暫譯: 它在黑夜到訪)
IMDB: 6.6 RT: 88% MT: 78 (best 7th)
平均: 77.3

13th. Lady Macbeth (惡女馬克白)
IMDB: 7.1 RT: 88% MT: 76
平均: 78.3

12th. Okja (玉子)
IMDB: 7.5 RT: 85% MT: 76
平均: 78.7

11th. Detroit (底特律)
IMDB: 7.6 RT: 82% MT: 78 (best 7th)
平均: 78.7

10th. Wind River (極地追擊)
IMDB: 8.1 (best 2nd) RT: 86% MT: 73
平均: 80.0

9th. Logan Lucky (羅根好好運)
IMDB: 7.4 RT: 92% (best 6th) MT: 78 (best 7th)
平均: 81.3

8th. Spider-Man: Homecoming (蜘蛛人:返校日)
IMDB: 7.9 (best 6th) RT: 92% (best 6th) MT: 73
平均: 81.3

7th. Wonder Woman (神力女超人)
IMDB: 7.8 (best 9th) RT: 92% (best 6th) MT: 76
平均: 82.0

6th. Good Time (好時光)
IMDB: 8.1 (best 2nd) RT: 88% MT: 80 (best 6th)
平均: 83.0

5th. A Ghost Story (暫譯: 鬼的故事)
IMDB: 7.8 (best 9th) RT: 92% (best 6th) MT: 84 (best 4th)
平均: 84.7

4th. War for the Planet of the Apes (猩球崛起:終極決戰)
IMDB: 7.9 (best 6th) RT: 93% (best 2nd) MT: 82 (best 5th)
平均: 84.7

3rd. Baby Driver (玩命再劫)
IMDB: 8.1 (best 2nd) RT: 93% (best 2nd) MT: 86 (best 2nd)
平均: 86.7

2nd. The Big Sick (愛情昏迷中)
IMDB: 8.1 (best 2nd) RT: 98% (best 1st) MT: 86 (best 2nd)
平均: 88.3

1st. Dunkirk (敦克爾克大行動)
IMDB: 8.4 (best 1st) RT: 93% (best 2nd) MT: 94 (best 1st)
平均: 90.3

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 1.164.49.192
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/movie/M.1504608225.A.73D.html
推 tin0107: 是不是很多台灣沒上呀？
推 sam8921502: 有一部片好像跟版上的風向差很多耶
推 JEFF11503: 絕命是去年的片子嗎？
→ JEFF11503: 喔我看到了，夏季
推 darkbrigher: imbd 2.0 笑死 這大概史上最低吧 變型金剛都有5了
推 fonghai: 表情那部蝦到爆炸最低分
→ qn123456: 用這種方式算平均好像怪怪的......
懇請賜教
※ 編輯: peter220 (1.164.49.192), 09/05/2017 22:17:24
→ qn123456: 各評分網的一貫標準與口味本來就不同，連量尺都不一樣，
→ qn123456: 怎麼會直接把IMDB分數乘個10倍後和其他兩家一起平均？XD
→ qn123456: 更別提爛蕃茄自己分成「影評分」與「觀眾分」兩種分數，
→ qn123456: 上面列出來的%數更是「新鮮度平均」，不是給分，沒辦法
→ qn123456: 混在一起算吧.....
→ qn123456: 所謂的「新鮮度」就只是「新鮮」或「爛」二選一，最後去
→ qn123456: 統計所有樣本裡的新鮮比例，和那種10分或100分裡給幾分
→ qn123456: 的評分方式不一樣呀
→ AQUANGEL: 爛番茄的評分制度不同 很難定義分數 所謂爛番茄分數
→ AQUANGEL: 不過就是喜愛度百分比 可是對於喜愛的程度卻無法判斷
→ AQUANGEL: 1部70分沒啥大缺點的電影 爛番茄分數都會很高